10% Free Withdrawal Annuity Nonsense: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan

April 5, 2026
9 min
10% Free Withdrawal Annuity Nonsense: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
The Annuity Man®
Quick Quote
A real annuity rate with zero strings attached.
Get Started

🔢 Use Our FREE Annuity Calculators + Live Rate Feeds:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/annuity-calculator/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=calculator

📞 Book a Free 30-minute Call with The Annuity Man Team:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/book-a-call?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=book_a_call

📘 Get Your FREE Annuity Owner’s Manual:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/get-smarter/annuity-books?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=annuity_books

The “10 percent free withdrawal” pitch sounds great, but what does it really mean? In this Shootin’ It Straight With Stan episode, Stan explains why that feature is just a liquidity provision, not a bonus benefit, and why taking withdrawals can reduce the contractual guarantees and lifetime income attached to the policy.

Watch and Enjoy,
Stan The Annuity Man

ALL THINGS ANNUITIES
https://bit.ly/43yrKCL

LISTEN/WATCH FUN WITH ANNUITIES PODCAST
https://www.youtube.com/@funwithannuities

#StanTheAnnuityMan
#Annuity
#TheAnnuityMan
#Retirement

0:00
Welcome to Shooting It Straight with

0:01
Stan. I'm your host Stan the Annuity

0:02
Man. America's annuity agent licensed in

0:04
all 50 states. Pioneer of contractual

0:06
guarantees

0:07
only.

0:09
I guess we're also Zeke Zeke's behind

0:11
the camera. We're licensed in Puerto

0:12
Rico. Now, I can say that in a Spanish

0:14
accent because we have a Spanish

0:16
division which I'm very, very proud of.

0:18
Today's topic's an interesting one and

0:20
one that comes up occasionally when the

0:23
bad chicken dinner seminar annuity agent

0:26
expensive steak dinner seminar. I always

0:28
say, get the flet mn, get it medium

0:30
rare. You know, swallow the food, not

0:32
the pitch. This typically happens when

0:35
an index annuity gunslinger out there

0:37
that only sells index annuity, one

0:38
sizefits-all product. We have nothing

0:40
against index annuities, but it's not a

0:42
one-sizefits-all product. Um, that we're

0:45
talking about today that the 10%

0:48
um free withdrawal nonsense that's being

0:50
pitched out there. You know, we'll get I

0:52
got a call. The reason I'm doing this

0:53
video is people call me and I listen.

0:56
And the guy said, 'Well, you know, the

0:58
guy said, "Yeah, there's a 10% free

0:59
withdrawal on this one, too." Hey,

1:01
player. Okay, in the index annuity

1:04
world, pretty much every single one

1:07
either has a 7% or 10% free withdrawal.

1:09
Most have 10% free withdrawal, meaning

1:12
that you have access to your own money,

1:15
meaning that if you took that free

1:16
withdrawal, it's going to upset and

1:19
change the contractual guarantees of the

1:21
policy. Hello. But for some reason,

1:25
Johnny Apples Seed agent is like, "Yeah,

1:27
and you get a 10% free withdrawal."

1:29
Instead of saying the right thing, which

1:30
is there are liquidity provisions with

1:32
this index annuity. You can take out 10%

1:35
if you need to. I'd advise you not to

1:37
because it upsets the contractual

1:39
guarantee, but that's a liquidity

1:41
provision. But no, they sell it like

1:43
it's a like it's a benefit. They promote

1:46
it like it's a benefit. And so I'm, you

1:48
know, I'm talking to this guy and I'm

1:49
like, "Hey man, um, you did you get an

1:52
income writer on that?" Yay. Sold me on

1:54
them income writers, too. And got an

1:55
upfront bonus. By the way, upfront bonus

1:57
candy for the stupid. You know, there's

1:59
nobody giving money away at an annuity

2:01
company. And the bonus is just part of

2:03
the overall contractual guarantees. It

2:04
means nothing. If you think that the

2:07
bonus is free money, it's not free

2:08
money. There's not a philanthropist, an

2:10
annuity company that wakes up in the

2:11
morning going, I'm gonna give free I'm

2:13
gonna give money away. No, no, no. It's

2:15
a teaser to get you involved going. They

2:17
want you to be at the at the seminar.

2:19
Go, you know what, Martha? Shoot. That's

2:21
20% 25% bonus. That's well that's a good

2:25
deal. M not all the time. It can be. I

2:29
mean we quote all carriers for

2:30
contractual guarantees and typically

2:33
it's attached to income writers attached

2:36
to index annuities. But in this case the

2:38
guy's like yeah so many income right?

2:40
I'm like yeah and I got this 10% annual

2:43
you free withdrawal too. I said, 'D did

2:46
he tell you that if you took the 10%

2:48
free withdrawal out that it's going to

2:49
affect the lifetime income stream? Well,

2:52
no. Doesn't it just come out of the the

2:54
the the index side and not the income

2:57
writer side? Uh, no. Player, let me let

2:59
me give you a visual. Okay, draw a line

3:02
down a blank sheet of paper. Okay, this

3:04
side's the index annuity side. This

3:07
side's the income writer side. this side

3:09
you can't cash in, transfer or peel off

3:11
that yummy growth that they tell you

3:14
you're getting 8% on grow. That's not

3:15
yield player. That's that's it growing

3:18
by that amount. Okay, for lifetime

3:21
income and 8% don't mean anything. It's

3:23
all about the the bottom number. But

3:25
going back to income writer accumulation

3:27
value, the 10% is taken from both sides.

3:31
So if you say, I want that 10% free

3:33
withdrawal that Johnny Apples Seed agent

3:35
told me about because that's a good

3:36
deal. Well, you've lessened this amount,

3:39
which is your death benefit walkway

3:41
amount, but you've also lessened your

3:43
lifetime income amount because 10% comes

3:45
out of that account as well. Hello.

3:49
Weren't told that, were you? Wow, that's

3:51
interesting.

3:53
10% free withdrawal means you have

3:57
access to your own money. Okay, great.

4:00
Super. They put Thank you. Thank you,

4:02
annuity company, for putting in that

4:04
that liquidity provision. is nothing

4:06
more than a liquidity provision.

4:10
That's it.

4:12
You know, so in the in the sales pitch

4:14
you're hearing out there at the by the

4:16
by your advisors and people's pitching

4:18
index annuities. And by the way, we sell

4:21
more index annuities than anyone, but

4:22
the way that we feel that they should be

4:24
sold at the time of this taping is when

4:27
you attach an income writer for lifetime

4:29
income. You don't have to, but if you

4:31
answer the question, two questions we

4:33
always ask. What do you want the money

4:35
to contractually do? If you said that

4:37
income was the answer. And then the

4:39
second question, when do you want those

4:41
contractual guarantees to start? And you

4:43
said probably seven years from now, 5

4:45
years from now, nine years from now,

4:46
whatever, three years from now. Then we

4:49
attach an income writer for that

4:51
contractual guarantee. The contractual

4:53
guaranteed side is the income writer

4:55
side. Okay? So, if you're going into the

4:59
income writer side, that's your

5:00
contractual guarantee. That's the amount

5:02
of money you know to the penny what it's

5:04
going to be 7 years from now. Then you

5:06
got to understand that 10% free

5:08
withdrawal that Johnny Apples Seed agent

5:10
told you about. It's going to affect

5:11
that if you start taking it out. Now I

5:13
understand things happen. There's

5:14
events, there's emergencies, there's all

5:16
all kinds of stuff like that. It's

5:19
available to you and that's a good

5:20
thing. But what I don't want you to do

5:23
is think that's a that's a big deal. I

5:25
also don't want you to think that when

5:26
they say you get an upfront bonus,

5:29
that's not a big deal either. Who cares?

5:31
If if it affects in a positive way after

5:34
us quoting all carriers for lifetime

5:36
income that income writer side, great.

5:39
Then we'll choose it. Who cares? I don't

5:41
care. It's part of there's a 100 pennies

5:43
in the dollar. Okay. But don't say,

5:45
"Well, I'm getting a I'm getting This is

5:46
what the guy told me. I'm getting a 25%

5:48
upfront bonus and I got 10% free

5:50
withdrawal and and I'm getting long-term

5:52
care." No, you're not getting long-term

5:54
care because long-term care is a health

5:55
product. It's not a life insurance

5:56
product. Everything is wrong about that

5:59
pitch. And also, part of the pitch was,

6:01
"And I'm going to get market upside with

6:02
no downside." Wow. Holy mackerel. I

6:06
mean, you're talking about checking your

6:07
morals at the door as an agent with that

6:09
sales pitch. Ridiculous. And if you own

6:12
an an index annuity and were so already

6:15
and you were sold on the growth side,

6:17
market upside with no downside, market

6:19
participation, principal protection, you

6:22
know that's not true. Now, after two

6:24
years, you know it. And I'm going to

6:26
tell you right now, I've never and I I

6:28
the challenge is out there and it's big

6:30
money behind it. If you can show me

6:33
a hypothetical, theoretical back tested

6:36
proposal that you signed off on that you

6:39
bought and it came true or better. I've

6:42
been I've been putting that challenge

6:44
out there for 25 years. Nobody's taking

6:47
me up on it. Why? Because it never comes

6:49
true. Okay? And it will never come true

6:53
if you're taking 10% out. Well, I'm I

6:56
can take 10% out. It affects the whole

6:58
policy if you do that, Chester.

7:00
Okay. So, don't if it sounds too good to

7:03
be true is every single time without

7:05
exception with annuities without

7:06
exception. If you're interested in in an

7:09
income writer or index annuity with an

7:11
income writer, go to my site at

7:12
theanuityman.com

7:14
and run run quotes to your heart's

7:16
content. By the way, lifetime income, A+

7:18
or better. You don't need a sweater,

7:19
Zeke. It rhymes. A+ or better. You don't

7:22
need a sweater for lifetime income. You

7:24
got to make sure that company is solid

7:26
and going to be here. All right. Now,

7:30
everything that we recommend, I

7:31
personally sign off on. Everybody in my

7:33
Las Vegas office is licensed in all 50

7:35
states, but they are not on commission.

7:37
They follow my recommendations. I look

7:39
at every single case. All right. I do

7:42
that. You say, "Well, how's that?

7:43
Thousands of cases a week." Yeah,

7:45
absolutely. But I can look at them,

7:47
glance at them, know what they're going

7:48
to do, direct my team to do the right

7:49
thing, do exactly what I would do. And

7:51
if you want to get me on the phone, you

7:53
can do that. I'm not afraid of you,

7:55
player. Email me stantheanuityman.com.

7:58
stantheanuityman.com.

8:00
I'll I'll respond and we'll get

8:02
involved. I'll get involved personally.

8:03
One last thing, this yummy hat. You're

8:05
saying, Stan, you're so attractive in

8:07
those hats. Boy, I'd really like to get

8:09
a hat and see if I could pull that off,

8:11
too. You can. If you're a client

8:12
watching this and you don't have one,

8:14
sorry. Uh, we'll send you one. Just

8:16
shoot me an email. Again,

8:17
stantheanuitymen.com. If you're not a

8:18
client, but you're considering, no

8:20
obligation. will send you one as well.

8:21
You just got to give me a good reason

8:22
why. Again, stantheanuityman.com.

8:26
But I guess in closing about this 10%

8:30
free withdrawal, you know, and the

8:32
upfront bonuses, all that sound, if it

8:34
sounds too good to be true, it is every

8:35
single time. And when you take money out

8:37
of a policy, it affects the contractual

8:38
guarantees across the board.

8:42
Period. And if you haven't been told

8:44
that, shame on the agent for not telling

8:46
you that. You know, as my grandfather

8:48
always said, Zeke, if you tell the

8:49
truth, you don't have to remember

8:50
anything. And that's what we do here at

8:52
the Annuity Man. Are we not perfect? No,

8:54
we're not perfect, but we run toward the

8:56
bullets and we make sure that we solve

8:58
any type of problems or issues that you

9:00
may have. And we'll take you from start

9:02
to finish and across the finish line. If

9:04
you decide to work with us, we represent

9:06
all carriers and can pro provide the

9:08
highest contractual guarantees out

9:09
there. So, with that being said, my name

9:12
is Stan the Annuity Man, and that is

9:14
shooting it straight with Stan.

related videos

Fixed Index Annuity Pros and Cons
Fixed Index Annuity Pros and Cons
How Is An Immediate Annuity Funded?
How Is An Immediate Annuity Funded?
Do Fixed Annuities Have Fees?
Do Fixed Annuities Have Fees?

Talk to Stan The Annuity Man® himself

Get Stan for 30 minutes. No cost for his 3 decades of experience. Prepare yourself for the brutal annuity truth.

Book Your Call with Stan