10% Free Withdrawal Annuity Nonsense: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan

April 5, 2026
9 min
10% Free Withdrawal Annuity Nonsense: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
The Annuity Man®
Quick Quote
A real annuity rate with zero strings attached.
Get Started

🔢 Use Our FREE Annuity Calculators + Live Rate Feeds:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/annuity-calculator/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=calculator

📞 Book a Free 30-minute Call with The Annuity Man Team:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/book-a-call?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=book_a_call

📘 Get Your FREE Annuity Owner’s Manual:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/get-smarter/annuity-books?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=annuity_books

The “10 percent free withdrawal” pitch sounds great, but what does it really mean? In this Shootin’ It Straight With Stan episode, Stan explains why that feature is just a liquidity provision, not a bonus benefit, and why taking withdrawals can reduce the contractual guarantees and lifetime income attached to the policy.

Watch and Enjoy,
Stan The Annuity Man

ALL THINGS ANNUITIES
https://bit.ly/43yrKCL

LISTEN/WATCH FUN WITH ANNUITIES PODCAST
https://www.youtube.com/@funwithannuities

#StanTheAnnuityMan
#Annuity
#TheAnnuityMan
#Retirement

0:00
Welcome to Shooting It Straight with

0:01
Stan. I'm your host Stan the Annuity

0:02
Man. America's annuity agent licensed in

0:04
all 50 states. Pioneer of contractual

0:06
guarantees

0:07
only.

0:09
I guess we're also Zeke Zeke's behind

0:11
the camera. We're licensed in Puerto

0:12
Rico. Now, I can say that in a Spanish

0:14
accent because we have a Spanish

0:16
division which I'm very, very proud of.

0:18
Today's topic's an interesting one and

0:20
one that comes up occasionally when the

0:23
bad chicken dinner seminar annuity agent

0:26
expensive steak dinner seminar. I always

0:28
say, get the flet mn, get it medium

0:30
rare. You know, swallow the food, not

0:32
the pitch. This typically happens when

0:35
an index annuity gunslinger out there

0:37
that only sells index annuity, one

0:38
sizefits-all product. We have nothing

0:40
against index annuities, but it's not a

0:42
one-sizefits-all product. Um, that we're

0:45
talking about today that the 10%

0:48
um free withdrawal nonsense that's being

0:50
pitched out there. You know, we'll get I

0:52
got a call. The reason I'm doing this

0:53
video is people call me and I listen.

0:56
And the guy said, 'Well, you know, the

0:58
guy said, "Yeah, there's a 10% free

0:59
withdrawal on this one, too." Hey,

1:01
player. Okay, in the index annuity

1:04
world, pretty much every single one

1:07
either has a 7% or 10% free withdrawal.

1:09
Most have 10% free withdrawal, meaning

1:12
that you have access to your own money,

1:15
meaning that if you took that free

1:16
withdrawal, it's going to upset and

1:19
change the contractual guarantees of the

1:21
policy. Hello. But for some reason,

1:25
Johnny Apples Seed agent is like, "Yeah,

1:27
and you get a 10% free withdrawal."

1:29
Instead of saying the right thing, which

1:30
is there are liquidity provisions with

1:32
this index annuity. You can take out 10%

1:35
if you need to. I'd advise you not to

1:37
because it upsets the contractual

1:39
guarantee, but that's a liquidity

1:41
provision. But no, they sell it like

1:43
it's a like it's a benefit. They promote

1:46
it like it's a benefit. And so I'm, you

1:48
know, I'm talking to this guy and I'm

1:49
like, "Hey man, um, you did you get an

1:52
income writer on that?" Yay. Sold me on

1:54
them income writers, too. And got an

1:55
upfront bonus. By the way, upfront bonus

1:57
candy for the stupid. You know, there's

1:59
nobody giving money away at an annuity

2:01
company. And the bonus is just part of

2:03
the overall contractual guarantees. It

2:04
means nothing. If you think that the

2:07
bonus is free money, it's not free

2:08
money. There's not a philanthropist, an

2:10
annuity company that wakes up in the

2:11
morning going, I'm gonna give free I'm

2:13
gonna give money away. No, no, no. It's

2:15
a teaser to get you involved going. They

2:17
want you to be at the at the seminar.

2:19
Go, you know what, Martha? Shoot. That's

2:21
20% 25% bonus. That's well that's a good

2:25
deal. M not all the time. It can be. I

2:29
mean we quote all carriers for

2:30
contractual guarantees and typically

2:33
it's attached to income writers attached

2:36
to index annuities. But in this case the

2:38
guy's like yeah so many income right?

2:40
I'm like yeah and I got this 10% annual

2:43
you free withdrawal too. I said, 'D did

2:46
he tell you that if you took the 10%

2:48
free withdrawal out that it's going to

2:49
affect the lifetime income stream? Well,

2:52
no. Doesn't it just come out of the the

2:54
the the index side and not the income

2:57
writer side? Uh, no. Player, let me let

2:59
me give you a visual. Okay, draw a line

3:02
down a blank sheet of paper. Okay, this

3:04
side's the index annuity side. This

3:07
side's the income writer side. this side

3:09
you can't cash in, transfer or peel off

3:11
that yummy growth that they tell you

3:14
you're getting 8% on grow. That's not

3:15
yield player. That's that's it growing

3:18
by that amount. Okay, for lifetime

3:21
income and 8% don't mean anything. It's

3:23
all about the the bottom number. But

3:25
going back to income writer accumulation

3:27
value, the 10% is taken from both sides.

3:31
So if you say, I want that 10% free

3:33
withdrawal that Johnny Apples Seed agent

3:35
told me about because that's a good

3:36
deal. Well, you've lessened this amount,

3:39
which is your death benefit walkway

3:41
amount, but you've also lessened your

3:43
lifetime income amount because 10% comes

3:45
out of that account as well. Hello.

3:49
Weren't told that, were you? Wow, that's

3:51
interesting.

3:53
10% free withdrawal means you have

3:57
access to your own money. Okay, great.

4:00
Super. They put Thank you. Thank you,

4:02
annuity company, for putting in that

4:04
that liquidity provision. is nothing

4:06
more than a liquidity provision.

4:10
That's it.

4:12
You know, so in the in the sales pitch

4:14
you're hearing out there at the by the

4:16
by your advisors and people's pitching

4:18
index annuities. And by the way, we sell

4:21
more index annuities than anyone, but

4:22
the way that we feel that they should be

4:24
sold at the time of this taping is when

4:27
you attach an income writer for lifetime

4:29
income. You don't have to, but if you

4:31
answer the question, two questions we

4:33
always ask. What do you want the money

4:35
to contractually do? If you said that

4:37
income was the answer. And then the

4:39
second question, when do you want those

4:41
contractual guarantees to start? And you

4:43
said probably seven years from now, 5

4:45
years from now, nine years from now,

4:46
whatever, three years from now. Then we

4:49
attach an income writer for that

4:51
contractual guarantee. The contractual

4:53
guaranteed side is the income writer

4:55
side. Okay? So, if you're going into the

4:59
income writer side, that's your

5:00
contractual guarantee. That's the amount

5:02
of money you know to the penny what it's

5:04
going to be 7 years from now. Then you

5:06
got to understand that 10% free

5:08
withdrawal that Johnny Apples Seed agent

5:10
told you about. It's going to affect

5:11
that if you start taking it out. Now I

5:13
understand things happen. There's

5:14
events, there's emergencies, there's all

5:16
all kinds of stuff like that. It's

5:19
available to you and that's a good

5:20
thing. But what I don't want you to do

5:23
is think that's a that's a big deal. I

5:25
also don't want you to think that when

5:26
they say you get an upfront bonus,

5:29
that's not a big deal either. Who cares?

5:31
If if it affects in a positive way after

5:34
us quoting all carriers for lifetime

5:36
income that income writer side, great.

5:39
Then we'll choose it. Who cares? I don't

5:41
care. It's part of there's a 100 pennies

5:43
in the dollar. Okay. But don't say,

5:45
"Well, I'm getting a I'm getting This is

5:46
what the guy told me. I'm getting a 25%

5:48
upfront bonus and I got 10% free

5:50
withdrawal and and I'm getting long-term

5:52
care." No, you're not getting long-term

5:54
care because long-term care is a health

5:55
product. It's not a life insurance

5:56
product. Everything is wrong about that

5:59
pitch. And also, part of the pitch was,

6:01
"And I'm going to get market upside with

6:02
no downside." Wow. Holy mackerel. I

6:06
mean, you're talking about checking your

6:07
morals at the door as an agent with that

6:09
sales pitch. Ridiculous. And if you own

6:12
an an index annuity and were so already

6:15
and you were sold on the growth side,

6:17
market upside with no downside, market

6:19
participation, principal protection, you

6:22
know that's not true. Now, after two

6:24
years, you know it. And I'm going to

6:26
tell you right now, I've never and I I

6:28
the challenge is out there and it's big

6:30
money behind it. If you can show me

6:33
a hypothetical, theoretical back tested

6:36
proposal that you signed off on that you

6:39
bought and it came true or better. I've

6:42
been I've been putting that challenge

6:44
out there for 25 years. Nobody's taking

6:47
me up on it. Why? Because it never comes

6:49
true. Okay? And it will never come true

6:53
if you're taking 10% out. Well, I'm I

6:56
can take 10% out. It affects the whole

6:58
policy if you do that, Chester.

7:00
Okay. So, don't if it sounds too good to

7:03
be true is every single time without

7:05
exception with annuities without

7:06
exception. If you're interested in in an

7:09
income writer or index annuity with an

7:11
income writer, go to my site at

7:12
theanuityman.com

7:14
and run run quotes to your heart's

7:16
content. By the way, lifetime income, A+

7:18
or better. You don't need a sweater,

7:19
Zeke. It rhymes. A+ or better. You don't

7:22
need a sweater for lifetime income. You

7:24
got to make sure that company is solid

7:26
and going to be here. All right. Now,

7:30
everything that we recommend, I

7:31
personally sign off on. Everybody in my

7:33
Las Vegas office is licensed in all 50

7:35
states, but they are not on commission.

7:37
They follow my recommendations. I look

7:39
at every single case. All right. I do

7:42
that. You say, "Well, how's that?

7:43
Thousands of cases a week." Yeah,

7:45
absolutely. But I can look at them,

7:47
glance at them, know what they're going

7:48
to do, direct my team to do the right

7:49
thing, do exactly what I would do. And

7:51
if you want to get me on the phone, you

7:53
can do that. I'm not afraid of you,

7:55
player. Email me stantheanuityman.com.

7:58
stantheanuityman.com.

8:00
I'll I'll respond and we'll get

8:02
involved. I'll get involved personally.

8:03
One last thing, this yummy hat. You're

8:05
saying, Stan, you're so attractive in

8:07
those hats. Boy, I'd really like to get

8:09
a hat and see if I could pull that off,

8:11
too. You can. If you're a client

8:12
watching this and you don't have one,

8:14
sorry. Uh, we'll send you one. Just

8:16
shoot me an email. Again,

8:17
stantheanuitymen.com. If you're not a

8:18
client, but you're considering, no

8:20
obligation. will send you one as well.

8:21
You just got to give me a good reason

8:22
why. Again, stantheanuityman.com.

8:26
But I guess in closing about this 10%

8:30
free withdrawal, you know, and the

8:32
upfront bonuses, all that sound, if it

8:34
sounds too good to be true, it is every

8:35
single time. And when you take money out

8:37
of a policy, it affects the contractual

8:38
guarantees across the board.

8:42
Period. And if you haven't been told

8:44
that, shame on the agent for not telling

8:46
you that. You know, as my grandfather

8:48
always said, Zeke, if you tell the

8:49
truth, you don't have to remember

8:50
anything. And that's what we do here at

8:52
the Annuity Man. Are we not perfect? No,

8:54
we're not perfect, but we run toward the

8:56
bullets and we make sure that we solve

8:58
any type of problems or issues that you

9:00
may have. And we'll take you from start

9:02
to finish and across the finish line. If

9:04
you decide to work with us, we represent

9:06
all carriers and can pro provide the

9:08
highest contractual guarantees out

9:09
there. So, with that being said, my name

9:12
is Stan the Annuity Man, and that is

9:14
shooting it straight with Stan.

related videos

What Is A Life Insurance Annuity?
What Is A Life Insurance Annuity?
MYGAs Are Annuity Bonds: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
MYGAs Are Annuity Bonds: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
What Does A 10-Year Certain And Life Annuity Mean?
What Does A 10-Year Certain And Life Annuity Mean?

Talk to Stan The Annuity Man® himself

Get Stan for 30 minutes. No cost for his 3 decades of experience. Prepare yourself for the brutal annuity truth.

Book Your Call with Stan