Christine Benz: Avoiding Blind Spots in Your Retirement Portfolio Planning (From the Vault)

January 6, 2026
50 min
Christine Benz: Avoiding Blind Spots in Your Retirement Portfolio Planning (From the Vault)
The Annuity Man®
Quick Quote
A real annuity rate with zero strings attached.
Get Started

In this insightful replay, Stan The Annuity Man sits down with Christine Benz — Director of Personal Finance and Retirement Planning for Morningstar — to talk about how retirees should think about spending, portfolio withdrawals, diversification, and the realities of decumulation.

They discuss:

Why Christine is so passionate about financial education and retirement portfolio planning

Why decumulation isn’t bad — and when it can actually be a good thing

Common retirement blindspots most people overlook

How variable and unexpected costs fit into a retirement spending plan

How the “bucket approach” works for retirement portfolios

Highlights:

Your portfolio doesn’t care whether withdrawals come from income or from selling appreciated securities. What really matters is that you aren’t taking out too much.

Many people overestimate how long they’ll keep working — and often retire earlier than expected due to health, job loss, or life changes.

Diversification across income sources and investments is powerful. No single product or asset class solves everything.

Annuities come in many different forms. The “best” one depends entirely on your specific goals, needs, and situation — not a one-size-fits-all pitch.

Quote to remember:
“If you're looking for something that will zig when your stocks zag, you probably want to ensure that your portfolio includes that cash and treasury bonds.” — Christine Benz

Connect with Christine Benz:
Website: https://www.morningstar.com/
Podcast: https://www.morningstar.com/podcasts/the-long-view
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/christine-benz-b83b523/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/christine_benz
Book: Morningstar’s 30 Minute Money Solutions: https://www.amazon.com/Morningstars-30-Minute-Money-Solutions-Step/dp/0470918136
Book: Morningstar Guide to Mutual Funds
https://www.amazon.com/Morningstar-Guide-Mutual-Funds-Strategies/dp/0470137533
Christine’s Article Archive: http://www.morningstar.com/articles/author/30-christine-benz.aspx

LISTEN ON ALL YOUR FAVORITE PODCAST PLATFORMS:
Libsyn: https://directory.libsyn.com/shows/view/id/theannuityman
Stitcher: https://www.stitcher.com/podcast/niceguysonbusiness/the-annuity-man-podcast#/
Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/fun-with-annuities-the-annuity-man-podcast/id1482993601
Google: https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly90aGVhbm51aXR5bWFuLmxpYnN5bi5jb20vcnNz?sa=X&ved=0CAMQ27cFahcKEwjgu6j7suzrAhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQAQ Amazon: https://music.amazon.com/podcasts/11fec7ab-59ab-402f-94c7-93860e1694ae/Fun-with-Annuities-The-Annuity-Man-Podcast
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/26y3c7vXgnhfmErLRP3zuM

CONNECT WITH STAN
Call Stan The Annuity Man: 800-509-6473
Website: http://theannuityman.com/
Email: [email protected]
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/stantheannuityman/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/StanAnnuityMan
TikTok: https://www.tiktok.com/@theannuityman
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/theannuityman/

Use the Calculators - https://www.stantheannuityman.com/annuity-calculator/
Get The Annuity Man's Books - https://www.stantheannuityman.com/how-do-annuities-work
Schedule a time to talk to Stan - https://www.stantheannuityman.com/book-a-call/

FUN WITH ANNUITIES (r)

0:04
Welcome to Fun with Annuities, where

0:06
every single week I welcome a celebrity

0:08
guest expert that can help you maximize

0:10
[music]

0:11
chapter 2 of your life. Listen, learn,

0:14
laugh, and love every minute of the most

0:17
unique financial podcast on the planet.

0:21
Let's get to it.

0:29
Welcome to Fun with Annuities, the

0:31
number one annuity podcast on the

0:32
planet. I'm your host, Stan the Annuity

0:33
Man, America's annuity agent. I want to

0:36
welcome everyone listening to us on the

0:39
on all the podcast platforms. And also

0:41
remember, I have two YouTube channels.

0:42
One Stan the Annuity Man YouTube

0:44
channel, which has up to 400 product

0:47
videos that are very short and

0:48
informative and non-salesy about annuity

0:50
products. And then this podcast, Fund

0:52
with Annuities, has its own YouTube

0:53
channel which where you can go and and

0:55
view the guest and myself interacting

0:57
and the facial expressions and all that

0:59
good stuff. But I don't want to waste

1:00
any time because today's guest is a true

1:03
superstar. Her name is Christine Benz.

1:05
And let me tell you a little bit about

1:06
her. She is the director of personal

1:08
finance for Morning Star. You know what

1:11
Morning Star is. And a senior columnist

1:13
for Morningstar.com as well. Her primary

1:16
focus is on retirement and portfolio

1:19
planning for individual investors, which

1:20
is the reason that you're listening. Uh

1:22
she's she also co-hosts a podcast for

1:25
Morning Star. It's called The Long View.

1:27
I encourage you to listen to that

1:28
because they they bring in people and

1:31
interview them, you know, thought

1:32
leaders and in the investing and

1:34
personal finance space. Couple things

1:36
about Christine that you need to know.

1:38
In 2020, Baron's named her to its

1:40
inaugural list of the 100 most

1:43
influential women in finance. and she

1:44
also appeared on that list in 2021 as

1:46
well and and she's going to be on that

1:48
list for infinity [laughter]

1:51
in 2021. Baron's also named her as one

1:53
of the the the 10 most influential women

1:56
in wealth management. You can just

1:58
probably remove the women. She's

2:00
probably the one of the most 10

2:01
influential people in wealth management.

2:04
She's al also the author of a book

2:06
called the 30 minute money solutions, a

2:09
step-by-step guide to managing your

2:10
finances, which I encourage you to read.

2:13
She also co-authored a book called

2:14
Morning Stars Guide to Mutual Funds,

2:17
which is the five-star strategies for

2:18
success. That's kind of the underlying

2:20
title, which you know, it's been a

2:22
bestseller since 2003, and she put out

2:24
the second edition and helped do that in

2:26
2005. Pretty interesting background from

2:28
an educational standpoint. Christine

2:29
holds a b a bachelor's of education, uh,

2:32
a bachelor's degree in political science

2:34
in Russian and East European studies

2:36
from the University of Illinois. I think

2:37
that's that's really fascinating. She's

2:40
also a board member of the John C. Bogle

2:42
Center for Financial Literacy and is

2:44
also a member of what's called the Alpha

2:46
Group, which consists of the top thought

2:47
leaders in wealth management uh across

2:50
the country. Now, when she has free

2:52
time, which is sounds like she doesn't

2:54
have a ton, but when she does, she works

2:56
with underprivileged women to improve

2:57
their understanding of personal finance

3:00
concepts, which is fantastic. Now, on my

3:02
site at theanuityman.com, we are going

3:04
to have links to her archives that are

3:07
on morningstar.com where you can read I

3:09
mean, she's a great writer. can read her

3:11
stuff and we're also going to have a

3:12
link to her podcast replays as well. I

3:16
could keep going. I mean that I

3:17
synopsized the bio, believe me. But I

3:20
want to welcome Christine Benz to Fun

3:22
with Annuities. Welcome Christine.

3:24
Stan, thank you so much. Gosh, that was

3:26
such a nice introduction. I really

3:28
appreciate it and I'm happy to be here

3:30
today.

3:30
Well, you've earned it obviously. So,

3:32
let's just jump right in. Um, you know,

3:34
you're very very passionate about um

3:37
retirement portfolio planning. What are

3:40
some of the reasons that you're so

3:42
passionate about that? I know that you

3:43
have told me that I I wrote them all

3:45
down, but I want you to tell the people

3:46
why, you know, why this is such a

3:48
driving force for you on a daily basis.

3:51
Sure. Well, I would start with saying

3:53
that it's personal for me because I have

3:56
helped older adults in my life through

3:58
this process. My parents, my in-laws, um

4:02
both my husbands and my dads have since

4:05
passed away and and my mom has passed

4:06
away as well. I still have my

4:07
mother-in-law, but I've helped them

4:09
through this process and through that

4:11
really began to recognize

4:14
that retirement deumulation is so much

4:17
more complicated than it was a couple of

4:20
decades ago, certainly 30 or 40 years

4:22
ago, where you have more and more people

4:25
like myself who are retiring without the

4:27
benefit of pensions. Uh more and more uh

4:31
folks will be coming into retirement

4:33
without a pension. But then you also

4:35
have this very low yield environment and

4:38
that has driven some retirees especially

4:40
I would to generalize a little bit some

4:43
of the older retirees

4:45
tend to gravitate to very income

4:48
ccentric portfolios they quite

4:50
reasonably want to try to subsist on

4:52
whatever yield their portfolio kicks

4:55
off. The odd thing about that today is

4:58
that if you or were to structure a

5:00
portfolio strictly for yield, you end up

5:02
with a pretty risky portfolio. So there

5:04
are the challenges of the current

5:06
environment. Another reason I'm

5:08
attracted to this space is that I am

5:11
involved in financial education

5:13
generally and one thing I know from

5:15
having worked with various groups is

5:17
that people are receptive to learn at

5:21
point of purchase sort of when they have

5:23
to make a decision about something. So,

5:25
you know, if it's a 401k investor, if

5:27
you give them a little bit of

5:28
information about how to make a sane

5:31
allocation within a 401k plan, they'll

5:33
be good to go and they'll listen to you.

5:36
Same goes for retirees. They need to

5:38
figure this out. If they are getting to

5:41
retirement, they need to figure out how

5:43
to extract cash flows from their

5:45
portfolios. They need to figure out how

5:47
much they can safely take out without

5:49
overspending. So, they're incredibly

5:51
receptive. I speak to these groups of

5:54
retirees and they are so engaged. There

5:56
are no sleepers in the audience when I

5:59
talk about retirement planning because

6:00
they really have a need to know this

6:03
information. Um, and then I guess

6:05
another reason why I like kind of being

6:07
in the um, public space to talk about

6:11
these issues is that I think that

6:14
unfortunately there's a little bit of a

6:15
tendency in the financial services

6:17
industry to make things a more

6:19
complicated than they need to be. And so

6:22
I like being a voice of uh, reason in

6:26
terms of saying it doesn't have to be

6:28
really complicated. You can do this in a

6:30
slightly simpler way. So those are some

6:33
of the highlights of why I like um being

6:36
in this space. And I guess just on

6:38
another personal note um the I know that

6:42
um cognitive decline is a major issue

6:44
among older adults. We had we

6:46
experienced that with with my dad later

6:48
in life and I was so happy that I was um

6:51
his investment buddy during his later

6:54
years and I was it was really pretty

6:56
seamless for us where I was able to take

6:58
over my parents investment plans. I know

7:01
a lot of older adults don't necessarily

7:03
have that trusted adult child who

7:06
understands investments. So, I like to

7:09
do education about this and I like to

7:11
help people create a a plan that could

7:15
effectively manage itself if need be for

7:18
a time or you know for the rest of their

7:20
lives. So, those are just just some of

7:22
the highlights of why I like to talk

7:24
about this area so much.

7:26
When you say the word de accumulation,

7:28
you know, we live in a world where we've

7:30
been taught accumulation. So when you

7:32
say the word de accumulation, I think a

7:34
lot of people instinctively reflex

7:36
because in essence, what they're what

7:38
they that says to them is my money is

7:41
going to decrease. I do me a favor and

7:44
do the do the listeners and viewers a

7:47
favor and tell them that deumulation's

7:49
okay and why

7:51
it is. And um you know I I do think that

7:54
many retirees do have that reflexive

7:56
desire to not touch their principle to

7:59
try to live off of yield. Um, but I

8:03
guess that my point is and the

8:05
philosophy that I bring to this is that

8:07
if you create the best possible

8:11
portfolio that you can with a sane mix

8:13
of risk and reward characteristics, that

8:16
portfolio doesn't know whether your

8:18
withdrawals are coming from income or

8:20
they're coming from selling appreciated

8:23
securities. What matters is that you are

8:26
not taking out too much and that you're

8:29
also maintaining that portfolio's

8:31
risk-reward characteristics as the years

8:34
go by. That's really the name of the

8:36
game. And I wouldn't get overly hung up

8:38
on never touching principle because

8:41
sometimes touching principle is actually

8:43
the right thing to do. So right now, for

8:45
example, we've had this tremendous run

8:48
in the equity market. My view has been

8:51
that if you're retired and you're

8:53
looking at what are still very low

8:55
yields today, your cash flows for at

8:57
least the next couple of years are

9:00
hiding in plain sight in terms of

9:02
harvesting some of those appreciated

9:04
equity securities, putting that money

9:06
into safe investments, probably cash,

9:09
short-term bonds, but essentially

9:11
setting aside your cash flows for the

9:13
next couple of years, and simultaneously

9:15
you are reducing risk in your investment

9:18
portfolio. So my view is that it's

9:21
perfectly okay to pull from those

9:24
appreciated positions. In fact, that

9:26
very much should be part of your

9:28
deumulation plan. And you shouldn't

9:30
worry too much about doing so if in the

9:33
end you're able to maintain your

9:36
portfolio and and maintain a a

9:38
sustainable withdrawal rate and make

9:40
sure that your money lasts throughout

9:41
your retirement years. That's a that's a

9:43
great explan explanation of deumulation

9:45
because I think that's almost a curse

9:47
word with a lot of people because they

9:48
they they were they remember Jimmy

9:51
Carter yields, you know, and I always

9:53
tell people, you know, Jimmy Carter's

9:54
building houses in Georgia, hopefully

9:55
hopefully he's still alive um at the

9:57
time of this taping, but um you're not

9:59
going to probably see those yields

10:01
anymore, those those 12% CD. So that's

10:03
tough for people. Um even though if you

10:06
look at the the 10-year Treasury

10:07
equivalents across the globe, we're

10:09
still pretty high. Um but high high

10:11
right now feels low

10:13
from a yield standpoint. One of the

10:15
I was doing some research on your

10:16
writings and it was fascinating. Um

10:19
you had a you had an article and and

10:21
I've seen you speak on this on some of

10:22
the blind spots that people um run into

10:26
and people miss when it comes to

10:28
retirement. And I think this is so

10:29
important because you know with with

10:31
over 10,000 baby boomers hitting the age

10:33
of 65 every single day. I mean it's a

10:35
demographic title wave. That's what I

10:37
call it,

10:38
right? Um, what are some of these blind

10:40
spots that people need to be aware of?

10:43
Um, and again, you don't have to write

10:44
it down everybody, especially if you're

10:46
driving or on that treadmill. I mean,

10:47
that you're going to We'll have these

10:48
replays up, but but kind of go through

10:50
the blind spots. I think I was writing

10:52
them down. I think you had around six.

10:54
You might have more. Can you cover

10:55
those?

10:56
Sure. Sure. So, um, I have a

10:58
presentation that's kind of structured

11:00
along these lines. And um one of them

11:03
that I start out the presentation with

11:05
is retirement date risk. And I think

11:08
that that's often times not discussed

11:10
very much. But the bottom line is that

11:13
even though we might have this very what

11:15
we think is a very well-conceived plan

11:17
of when we might expect to retire. Um in

11:22
reality when we look at the data and my

11:23
colleague David Blanchett who I think is

11:25
kind of one of the leading lights in

11:27
retirement research has looked at

11:29
people's stated anticipated retirement

11:32
dates and when they actually retired.

11:34
And what his research shows is that

11:37
we're not very good at this. We tend to

11:39
overestimate our ability to continue

11:41
working or our desire to continue

11:44
working. We we might say well I plan to

11:46
you know retire when I'm 69 or something

11:48
like that. When we look at the data, we

11:50
see that there's a gap that people

11:52
oftentimes are retiring earlier than

11:55
they expected to. And there are variety

11:57
of reasons why this might be. We know

11:59
that ageism is a thing in the workplace.

12:02
We know that older adults sometimes

12:04
encounter health issues or their spouse

12:07
encounters health issues that makes it

12:08
difficult for them to continue

12:10
or their parents

12:12
or their parents. Um, so a lot of

12:14
different forces can work against your

12:18
desire to work longer specifically. So

12:21
we see that there's typically a gap

12:23
where people are often retiring earlier

12:25
than expected.

12:27
So that's kind of a risk factor for the

12:29
size of the portfolio,

12:33
but if you are overwithdrawing over a

12:36
longer time period, that is a risk

12:39
factor. So that's one of the key blind

12:42
spots that I would point to and and to

12:45
me that really

12:47
argues for thinking through well if I'm

12:50
not able to continue working until that

12:53
anticipated retirement date what's my

12:55
backup plan what's my plan B and I think

12:58
it's worth while for all of us really

13:01
through throughout our careers to be

13:03
thinking about well if this thing if

13:05
whatever I'm doing doesn't work for me u

13:08
due to workplace issues or lifestyle

13:10
issues or health issues. Could I

13:13
continue to earn some sort of income in

13:16
the meantime? And so I I that is sort of

13:19
a a piece of counsel that I would bring

13:21
to this and also just be aware that you

13:23
don't have as much control over that

13:25
retirement date as you might wish to

13:27
believe you have. So, is there there a

13:29
strategy or strategies that you would

13:32
tell people to do specifically if um and

13:34
you covered it a little bit about, hey,

13:36
I'm going to retire at 69 or 65. It's

13:39
tough, you know, especially because you

13:41
don't know where markets are going to go

13:42
or interest rates are going to go. How

13:44
do you advise people to be flexible with

13:46
that retirement date risk planning?

13:49
Well, so I think thinking about what

13:51
your backup plan is, certainly nurturing

13:53
your human capital and making sure that

13:56
you are continuing to prove yourself

13:58
valuable to your organization throughout

14:01
your career. I think we've all,

14:03
especially those of us who are home

14:04
office workers, we've all sort of had a

14:07
very uh quick ramp up into being savvy

14:11
about all different matters of

14:12
technology that we we've all had to be

14:14
our own IT staff. I think that's been

14:17
great. So continuing to nurture your

14:19
human capital, also thinking hard about

14:22
insurance planning. A real wild card is

14:25
in this is if you are premedicare and

14:28
somehow separated from your employer

14:30
provided health care earlier than you

14:32
anticipated, right?

14:33
Thinking through your plan for that is

14:36
absolutely essential. So those are some

14:38
of the key things from sort of a plan

14:41
uh aspect uh to to help protect

14:44
yourself.

14:46
One of the one of the uh risk and blind

14:48
spots was sequence of return risk that

14:51
you that you mentioned. And when people

14:53
typically hear that, they've heard it

14:55
before, but can you dumb it down? I

14:59
always tell people, you know, if you

15:00
can't explain it to a nine-year-old, no

15:02
offense to nine-year-olds, you either

15:04
shouldn't buy it or you, you know, it's

15:05
not simplified enough. Simplify it down.

15:08
Sequence of return risk for the people

15:09
out there that aren't really sure what

15:11
that is,

15:12
right? It it's a a concept that

15:14
retirement researchers call talk about

15:17
and basically the risk is that you may

15:20
retire into a not so great market

15:23
environment. So when we think about the

15:26
market environment today, what do we

15:28
know? Well, we know that yields are

15:29
pretty low. We've talked about that a

15:31
little bit. We also know that equity

15:33
valuations because we have had this

15:35
longunning bull market, equity

15:38
valuations, stock prices aren't what

15:40
they once were. And so it's risky if you

15:43
come into retirement and you do

15:46
encounter a weak market environment for

15:48
whatever reason. Inflation I think is

15:50
potentially a consideration today as

15:52
well. The risk is that if you

15:54
overwithdraw

15:56
during that period that the market is

15:58
down, whether that's, you know, six

16:01
months or whether it's two and a half

16:02
years, whatever, if you're taking too

16:04
much from your portfolio during that

16:07
time and that time occurs in the early

16:09
years of your retirement, well, that

16:12
leaves less of your portfolio in place

16:14
to recover and to rebound when stocks

16:18
eventually do. So, it's a big risk

16:20
factor for new retirees. If you're an

16:23
older retiree, if you're someone who is

16:26
80 and you've been retired 15 years,

16:28
well, guess what? You've won. You have

16:30
retired into a pretty good market

16:31
environment. It's the new retirees who I

16:34
think need to be cautious and need to be

16:36
thinking about, well, what's my plan in

16:38
that instance? How do I structure my

16:41
plan so that I can protect myself

16:44
against that possibility of retiring

16:46
into a weak market?

16:48
And it sequence of return risk is

16:50
something you obviously can't control.

16:51
similar to dovetailing into one of the

16:53
other blind spots, which is the the low

16:55
yield environment that we're in that um

16:58
a lot of the savers and the CD buyers

17:00
are scratching their heads because the

17:02
the yield isn't there. The coupons

17:04
aren't there.

17:05
You know, no one knows where interest

17:07
rates are going to go, including

17:08
Christine Vince. She'll be the first

17:09
[laughter] one to tell you that. She'll

17:10
pound the table and tell you that. But

17:12
what's your advice for people in in a

17:15
environment that's low and it doesn't

17:16
seem like, you know, the government's

17:19
painted themselves into a little bit of

17:20
a corner printing all this money. So

17:21
raising interest rates, they're going to

17:22
raise those payments on themselves. So

17:24
it'd be like me and you raising our

17:25
mortgage rates, right? What's your

17:27
advice to people here other than grin

17:31
and bear, right? What is it? What do you

17:33
tell people? Well, I think it it's

17:36
worthwhile to rethink why you hold safer

17:38
assets in your portfolio and why you

17:41
just sort of decide to accept lower

17:44
yields. That the key reason is that yes,

17:48
cash and bond, high quality bonds are

17:52
there to provide you with yield, but

17:54
they're also there to be the ballast for

17:56
your equity portfolio. They are there to

17:58
be the assets that you could spend

18:01
through. If you comehead come into

18:03
retirement and you encounter a weak

18:06
equity market, you have set yourself up

18:08
with safe assets that you could spend

18:11
through before you need to touch the

18:14
equity assets. So I think re sort of

18:16
rethinking the role of safe assets that

18:20
income production is less of their value

18:23
today. That may change in the future.

18:25
right now their key value is safety a

18:29
and providing that cushion of some of

18:32
some sort of an equity market shock. So

18:35
that would be my advice. My advice

18:36
absolutely would be not to gravitate to

18:39
very high-risk high yield securities as

18:43
a big portion of your portfolio. We

18:45
might have them around the margins like

18:46
five or 10% in high yield bonds or

18:49
emerging markets bonds but definitely

18:51
not the main course because what when we

18:54
look at assets like that whether junk

18:56
bonds or or emerging markets bonds what

18:59
we see is very equity like performance

19:02
we see them behave in sympathy with the

19:04
equity market. That's not what you're

19:05
going for for this portion of your

19:07
portfolio. You're going for safety and

19:09
you have to contend with and accept very

19:12
low yields on offer today.

19:15
Which leads us to the grill in the room

19:16
and your blind spot that you list

19:18
sometimes in your presentations as

19:19
number four, which is inflation.

19:21
Yes.

19:21
Um, which people are very tuned into

19:25
because even though you hear government

19:27
officials sometimes say that there

19:29
really is an inflation, if you're buying

19:31
lumber and if you're buying food and if

19:32
you're buying gas and you know, you're

19:34
saying, "Wait a minute, I think there

19:35
might be." [laughter]

19:37
Obviously, in the annuity world, as you

19:39
know, um, annuity companies don't give

19:40
inflation increases away. they just

19:42
ratchet down the payments if you're

19:43
buying lifetime income. That didn't mean

19:45
it's good or bad, but that that also

19:46
means that there's no perfect solution

19:49
to inflation, just really bad sales

19:51
pitches, as I say. Um, what's your

19:54
what's your thought and advice for

19:56
people to think about, address, and and

20:00
strategize around inflation?

20:02
Yeah, it's a huge question today, Stan,

20:04
and a year ago, I wouldn't have been so

20:07
concerned with it, but we are beginning

20:09
to see inflation tick up. And I think,

20:11
you know, the big question is whether

20:12
this is just sort of a natural part of

20:14
this emergence from the lockdown that

20:18
we've been in for the better part of a

20:20
year, for more than a year. Um, but I

20:22
think from a retirement standpoint, you

20:24
think about protecting against inflation

20:26
in a few different ways. First, you

20:28
think about your own spending patterns

20:30
and do a little bit of um research, a

20:34
little bit of reconnaissance on what

20:36
your spending has looked like, what

20:38
categories you tend to spend on. One

20:40
thing we know about older adults is that

20:42
they spend more on health care than the

20:44
general population. We we have

20:47
historically seen health care inflation

20:50
rise at a faster clip than the general

20:53
inflation rate. So take a just take a

20:55
close look at your spending habits. In

20:58
some areas you may be a loser like

20:59
health care. Uh in other areas like

21:02
energy costs you may be a winner because

21:05
you're not commuting. You're not driving

21:07
as much as you were when you were

21:08
working. So kind of just think about

21:09
your spending categories and then think

21:13
about your income sources in retirement.

21:16
So if you are, you know, on the really

21:19
positive end of the spectrum from the

21:21
standpoint of inflation and you have

21:23
sort of a a a

21:25
pension that provides you full inflation

21:27
protection and that pension is supplying

21:30
you with all the income that you need,

21:32
well, you're in great shape. And then at

21:34
the other end of the spectrum would be

21:35
the retiree who doesn't have any of

21:37
those in inflation protected income

21:40
sources and has a really safe portfolio

21:43
that he or she is pulling from for all

21:45
of the income. Well, that's someone

21:46
who's really vulnerable because their

21:49
purchasing power is just going to be

21:50
gobbled up by inflation. Most of us in

21:53
retirement fall somewhere in between

21:55
those two poles where they we have some

21:58
inflation insulation. If we're getting

22:00
social security, for example, we might

22:02
not agree that the little increase that

22:05
we get on our social security benefit is

22:07
sufficient, but that portion of our

22:09
income is inflation protected. It's

22:12
really the portfolio that we need to

22:14
concern ourselves with to make sure that

22:16
that portion of our withdrawals is in

22:20
some fashion insulated against

22:21
inflation. So, when we think about

22:24
protecting a portfolio against

22:25
inflation, we think about a couple of

22:27
key categories. One would be to make

22:29
sure that you have

22:31
stocks in your portfolio because even

22:34
though stocks aren't any sort of direct

22:36
hedge against inflation, when we look at

22:38
the asset classes with the ability to

22:40
outearn inflation over time, stocks very

22:43
much fit the bill. Whether they will do

22:45
so over the next couple of years or the

22:47
next five years, open question. But over

22:49
longer time periods, we see a pretty

22:51
good ability for stocks to beat

22:54
inflation. So, you want to make sure you

22:55
have stocks. But on the fixed income

22:57
side, I think it's also worth looking at

23:00
a category called Treasury inflation

23:02
protected securities or sometimes called

23:04
TIPS, right?

23:05
And tips are issued by the Treasury, but

23:08
they have a little bit of spin on the

23:10
ball in terms of offering an inflation

23:13
adjustment to your principal value,

23:15
which in turns turn affects your yield

23:18
when inflation trends up. So my

23:22
colleagues at Morning Star Investment

23:24
Management put together asset allocation

23:26
programs within a a person's fixed

23:30
income allocation. They typically

23:32
recommend a retired person's fixed

23:33
income allocation. They typically

23:35
recommend like a 20 to 30% allocation to

23:39
Treasury inflation protected securities.

23:42
The idea is that you are protecting the

23:45
purchasing power on on that portion of

23:47
your portfolio. Some retirees might say,

23:50
"Well, why not just have my whole fixed

23:52
income allocation in TIPS?" Well, the

23:54
risk is that that's not very

23:55
diversified. So, even though Treasury

23:58
bonds and Treasury inflation protected

24:00
securities are the most creditw worthy

24:03
bonds that you can find, um they tend to

24:06
be somewhat interest rate sensitive. So,

24:09
you'd probably want to diversify to

24:11
include some corporate bonds, some

24:13
agencybacked bonds, some other

24:15
securities to ensure that your portfolio

24:18
uh your fixed income portfolio is a

24:20
little bit better diversified. But those

24:22
are some of the key asset classes I

24:24
would think about. Some of the other

24:26
asset classes that people might add

24:27
would would include things like

24:29
commodities or commodities tracking

24:32
exchange traded funds, precious metals,

24:35
either um uh uh an ETF like GLD or

24:40
perhaps some of the precious metals

24:42
mining companies. And here I would

24:44
recommend owning some type of a mutual

24:46
fund or an ETF, exchange traded fund

24:48
that does this. And finally, real

24:50
estate, I think, is another asset class

24:52
that historically has shown some ability

24:56
to protect against inflation. And the

24:58
reason is pretty intuitive that when

25:00
rates are increasing and as a REIT

25:04
owner, you're able to participate and

25:05
benefit from that. Well, that's also the

25:08
time when inflation is typically running

25:10
up broadly. So, those are some sort of

25:12
non-core assets that I might think

25:15
about, but again, keeping them to very

25:17
small positions because they're quite

25:19
volatile as standalone holdings. You

25:21
definitely don't want to have giant

25:24
positions in a category like commodities

25:27
or precious metals.

25:29
It's all about allocation and

25:30
proportion. And then you you preach that

25:32
with your your writings and what you've

25:34
done uh for for decades at at Morning

25:36
Star. one of the kind of the new

25:38
gorillas in the room and I read a couple

25:39
of recent articles that you have have

25:42
written on this topic is health care and

25:45
long-term care and obviously again the

25:47
demographic title of people hitting age

25:49
65 and and we're living longer etc.

25:53
tell tell people why this is important,

25:55
why long-term care coverage and that

25:57
transfer of risk type coverage they

26:00
should be looking at. Why why should

26:02
they do that?

26:03
Such an important topic, Stan. And um

26:06
I'll just start with talking about

26:07
health care expenses in retirement more

26:09
broadly. Fidelity annually puts out

26:12
these um estimates of what a 65year-old

26:16
couple who is retiring will spend over I

26:21
I believe it's like a 25 or 30 year

26:23
period. And the most recent information

26:26
that I saw was roughly $300,000. So

26:29
these are various premiums that they're

26:32
paying. These are out-ofpocket expenses

26:35
and so forth. So even after you're

26:36
covered by Medicare, you still have some

26:38
health care costs. And what we see when

26:40
we look at those health care costs is

26:42
that they're not linear. They're not the

26:43
same yearbyear. They tend to trend up

26:47
later in retirement. So Fidelity's

26:49
$300,000 estimate does not include

26:51
long-term care costs. That's just all

26:53
the other stuff that um people pay. So,

26:56
I think it's worth staying mindful about

26:59
those costs and certainly making sure

27:00
that you are incorporating them into

27:03
your budget and into your spending plan,

27:05
but also recognize that there's

27:07
tremendous variability in those costs.

27:09
So, giving some hard thought to what

27:12
your health situation is, what your

27:14
spouse's health situation is, where you

27:17
live is a big determinant of your

27:19
out-ofpocket health care outlay. So if

27:22
you live in a high-cost part of the

27:23
country, if you live in Chicago or LA or

27:26
some other city where high where costs

27:28
are high at large, you'll pay more for

27:31
health care. If you live in a less urban

27:33
area, you'll tend to pay less. So give

27:36
some thought to that. Make sure you're

27:37
factoring it into your budget. Also,

27:40
long-term care is uh the real wild card

27:43
in my view for many retirement plans. In

27:46
fact, when I'm out speaking, if there is

27:48
a topic that will send the room up for

27:50
grabs because it gives people so much

27:52
angst, it's this. People wonder how to

27:56
contend with long-term care costs. So,

27:58
these are costs that are not covered by

28:01
Medicare. They are costs that many older

28:03
adults incur if they encounter cognitive

28:06
decline or even if they just simply

28:08
start needing help around the home to

28:12
make meals or whatever it might be. um

28:15
to you know to help them shower or a lot

28:17
of um situations can occur. The idea is

28:21
that these costs are not going to be

28:24
covered by Medicare nor will they be

28:26
covered by your supplemental policy that

28:28
you may have purchased, right?

28:29
You need to create a plan for what these

28:32
long-term care costs might be and also

28:34
how you might contend with them. And so

28:36
it's super tricky because I often speak

28:40
to retirees who thought they were doing

28:42
exactly the right thing by purchasing

28:45
long-term care insurance. And what we've

28:47
seen is that the marketplace is pretty

28:49
troubled. That unfortunately these

28:51
policies that were priced 20 years ago

28:54
did not adequately incorporate long-term

28:57
care usage. Um, and they didn't

29:00
incorporate this very low yield

29:02
environment that we find ourselves in,

29:04
which has afflicted insurance companies

29:07
as well because they can't really earn

29:08
much on the premiums that they've been

29:10
able to take in if they want to be able

29:13
to make uh make their policy payments.

29:16
So, um, that's the the troubling part of

29:20
this. The easy answer 20 years ago might

29:23
have been to purchase some sort of a

29:26
long-term care policy. people have seen

29:28
their premiums really increase

29:30
to account for the fact that it's a

29:32
pretty troubled marketplace. So, I would

29:34
really um when thinking about this, when

29:37
approaching this risk, I would kind of

29:39
think about my own situation and sort

29:41
myself into one of three groupings. So

29:44
for people who don't have a lot in re in

29:47
retirement assets, they will probably to

29:50
the extent that they have long-term care

29:52
needs, they will be covered by Medicaid

29:55
and and Medicaid is the largest payer of

29:57
long-term care expenses in the US. Many

30:00
people end up needing Medicaid provided

30:03
care. So for people without a lot of uh

30:07
wealth that will be their um be their

30:10
strategy that they probably shouldn't

30:12
overly worry about it. Now it's worth

30:15
mentioning that you need to essentially

30:18
deplete most of your assets which could

30:21
leave your spouse um needing some sort

30:23
of u financial assistance in the

30:25
meantime. But that's sort of that group.

30:28
And then at the other ex extreme would

30:30
be very wealthy people who you know when

30:32
they look at their portfolios they have

30:34
more than enough to last during their

30:36
lifetimes and they can also cover an

30:39
extended long-term care need comfortably

30:42
out of their assets. I'm sometimes asked

30:44
well how much asked how much would I

30:47
need to have in assets to put me in this

30:49
other area where I'm self-funding

30:52
long-term care expenses. And my point is

30:55
I can't tell you that. I can't tell you

30:57
a dollar amount because I don't know

30:58
what you're spending from your

30:59
portfolio. Right?

31:00
If you have, you know, a $2 million

31:03
portfolio, but you are spending

31:06
too heavily from it, well, you probably

31:08
should have long-term care insurance.

31:11
So, um, get some guidance on that. If

31:14
you're a higher net worth person with a

31:17
sizable portfolio, make sure that you do

31:20
have adequate assets to self-fund

31:22
long-term care. And then my view is if

31:25
if you have determined that you have

31:26
enough, go ahead and segregate those

31:29
assets from your spendable assets to

31:31
ensure that you're not considering them

31:33
part of your spending plan. If you're a

31:35
young retiree and that's your plan to

31:37
self-fund long-term care, segregate

31:40
those assets. You'd probably want to

31:42
invest them pretty aggressively because

31:44
the chance of having a long-term care

31:46
need earlier in in your life is pretty

31:49
low. Um, and then that middle group is

31:52
the the group who I think is the best uh

31:56
candidate for some sort of insurance

31:58
product to help ensure against this

32:00
risk. You can still buy long-term care

32:03
policies, but increasingly what have

32:06
come on strong are these hybrid type

32:08
asset based Yeah. They call them

32:10
assetbased coverage. Yes.

32:11
Yes. which Stan, you know more about

32:13
these types of products than I do, but

32:15
it's typically either a life insurance

32:18
policy or an annuity with a long-term

32:20
care rider bolted on. And those can be

32:24
attractive options, especially in my

32:26
opinion, for people who had life

32:29
insurance and they had that need to

32:31
protect their dependence when their

32:33
dependents were younger. But if they're

32:35
older and they've accumulated sufficient

32:38
assets, life insurance may no longer be

32:41
a a big concern for them. Um, but they

32:44
can switch into one of these assetbased

32:47
policies to to help protect themselves

32:50
and they can do what's called a 1035

32:52
exchange,

32:53
get some tax guidance on this before

32:55
embarking on this. But um, these

32:57
policies, these products can be pretty

33:00
interesting in some situations. Maybe

33:02
not perfect, but um something to

33:05
consider and something to get some

33:07
unbiased advice about. Um you would

33:11
definitely want to engage the services

33:13
of some sort of a a financial planner or

33:16
advisor who is not selling these

33:18
products to help assist you in in doing

33:20
your due diligence because the products

33:22
can be a little complicated in my

33:24
experience. The hybrid

33:25
they certainly can. We had a um I had a

33:27
guest on recently. His name is Jack

33:29
Lindenberg. is arguably the top

33:30
long-term care expert in the country.

33:32
He's also a lawyer as a background. Um

33:34
but he talked about these assetbased um

33:37
long-term care solutions which covers

33:39
the biggest fear for most people which

33:41
is what if I don't use the what if I

33:43
don't use the coverage. These assetbased

33:45
policies protect the principle which

33:48
would go to your beneficiaries if you

33:49
didn't use it which is the biggest fear

33:51
of traditional long-term care which is I

33:53
pay in I pay in I pay in and it's you

33:55
know it goes poof when I die. with these

33:57
newer policies um you know that that

34:01
circumvents and gets rid of that fear

34:03
even though you have the coverage. So

34:05
you know uh I would encourage people if

34:07
you can go to my site at the

34:08
annuityman.com and re and relisten to

34:10
that podcast with Jack Lennenberg

34:11
because he's going to dovetail what

34:13
Christine's talking about but go into

34:15
detail about those specific products

34:17
which leads me to the the sixth blind

34:19
spot which which is where annuities can

34:21
fit in because they're the only product

34:23
on the planet that can provide lifetime

34:25
income. And it's a it's a blind spot

34:26
that you talk about. It's called

34:28
longevity risk. Can you go into that?

34:30
Yeah. You know, this is a good news

34:33
story in so many ways um that we see

34:36
life expectancy gains especially among

34:38
higher [music] income adults, right?

34:41
Um where you know the the probability of

34:45
if you're part of a married couple, the

34:46
probability of one of you making it to

34:48
age 95 is uh is quite high. I don't know

34:52
off the top of my head specifically what

34:54
it is, but it's it's I think it's one in

34:56
three.

34:56
Um, and when you further sort of

34:59
subdivide that group by higher income

35:02
adults, we unfortunately, in my opinion,

35:04
we see um longevity very much correlated

35:07
with level of wealth. And so we do know

35:10
that higher income, higher net worth

35:12
people tend to live longer. So you need

35:15
to protect yourself against that

35:17
possibility. Um, and there are a few

35:20
different ways to do that. I would say

35:22
that right out of the box, if you're

35:24
thinking about doing that, you want to

35:26
make sure that your money lasts. Well,

35:28
you certainly want to make sure that you

35:30
are looking at non-portfolio income

35:33
sources with an eye to maximizing those

35:35
lifetime [music] payouts. So, at the top

35:38
of the list would be to make sure that

35:40
you're making smart decisions about

35:41
social security claiming. And Stan, I

35:43
don't know if you agree with this

35:44
assertion, but I believe that that

35:47
should really be job one before you look

35:49
at an annuity just to make sure that you

35:51
are getting

35:52
I agree with that. I agree with that.

35:54
And the reason I agree with that, just

35:55
to interject real quick, is people

35:57
always say, "Well, I hate all

35:58
annuities." And I say, "Well, you

35:59
already own one, right?

36:00
And it's the best inflation annuity on

36:02
the planet." And they go, "No, I'll

36:04
never own an annuity." And Social

36:05
Security. So, I totally agree that

36:07
that's the foundational annuity

36:10
um that you need to make the best

36:11
decision on um and seek someone out, not

36:14
an agent or adviser, but someone who

36:16
really specializes in social security

36:18
type planning so that you can make that

36:20
decision for your situation because

36:22
there's no perfect answer across the

36:23
board. It's customizable to what you're

36:26
trying to do and achieve. I would think

36:27
absolutely. And if you're part of a

36:29
married couple, I think that decision-

36:31
making is even more important. Um, one

36:34
free tool I would note, Stan, is um,

36:36
from my friend Mike Piper who has a

36:39
website called Open Social Security.

36:41
It's a free website there. There's been

36:43
kind of a cottage industry in these

36:45
social security calculators. Mike's is

36:47
all uh, free and it's very rigorous.

36:50
Mike is a um, a CPA and a social

36:53
security expert. So, I would urge your

36:56
listeners to give that tool a trial run

36:58
because it's an absolutely terrific tool

37:00
and it helps you include different

37:02
variables that you don't necessarily see

37:04
everywhere. So, you can haircut your

37:06
potential benefits. If you're a younger

37:09
person, for example, and you're worried,

37:11
well, there might be changes to social

37:13
security down the line, you can factor

37:15
that in. You can also use different um

37:19
different actuarial tables that factor

37:22
in different health situations. So if

37:24
you think that you will be in especially

37:26
long lived retirees, you can take a look

37:28
at that. So I would urge people to check

37:30
that out.

37:31
What's that site again?

37:32
It's called Open Social Security.

37:34
So open social security. Open social

37:37
securitycurity.com I guess.

37:39
Yes, I believe so.

37:40
Okay, good. Um we'll we'll list that on

37:42
our on our site as well. But getting

37:44
back to longevity and that longevity

37:46
risk, you know, social security, big one

37:47
you got to plan for and and what I call

37:50
this is the income floor. What is your

37:52
income for? What is the money that's

37:53
coming into your account

37:54
that's going to hit every single month

37:56
to that will take care of you in what I

37:58
call chapter two of your life? Um, you

38:00
know, chapter chapter one is

38:01
accumulation, chapter two is

38:02
deaccumulation and going and living your

38:04
lifestyle. Um, where do you see

38:08
annuities get a really bad rap, but um,

38:10
they are the only product that can um,

38:13
provide income as long as you're

38:15
breathing. And I've seen you speak upon

38:17
about immediate annuities and the sister

38:19
product, deferred income annuities, and

38:20
also QAX, which are deferred income

38:22
annuities for IAS. Do you encourage

38:25
people to look at those, and it's okay

38:27
if you say you don't because annuities

38:29
aren't for everybody. I'm the first one

38:31
to say that. How does that how does that

38:33
those those transfer of risk lifetime

38:35
income products fit into your um

38:38
portfolio planning?

38:40
Yeah, I I do think that an annuity can

38:43
be a good fit for someone who has taken

38:45
the steps to look at what Social

38:48
Security will pay them

38:49
and to the extent that there's a gap in

38:52
terms of fulfilling their basic living

38:54
expenses, I think that an annuity can be

38:57
perfectly appropriate. Unfortunately, as

39:01
as you know better than anyone, Stan,

39:02
annuities um are incredibly complicated.

39:06
It's uh we were doing our podcast with

39:08
Carrie Pector who uh head of the

39:10
Retirement Income Journal. Sure. And

39:13
yeah, he made the point that you know

39:15
that the word annuity is almost useless

39:18
because the products under the annuity

39:21
umbrella are so incredibly varied.

39:24
There's many of them. Yeah. You can't

39:25
say you hate all annuities unless you

39:27
want to say I hate all restaurants. um

39:29
because it just um there's so many

39:31
types. Uh the annuity industry has done

39:33
a very poor job of um of explaining what

39:37
they are and what they can do and what

39:38
they solve for. Primarily, it's either

39:40
principal protection or or income for

39:43
life. One of those two. I can solve for

39:46
for legacy and long-term care. My

39:47
acronym I use is pill, you know,

39:49
principal protection, income for life,

39:50
legacy, and long-term care. And if you

39:52
don't if you if you don't want to solve

39:54
for any of those four, then you don't

39:55
need an annuity. So, that's kind of my

39:57
mantra. I do want to talk about, you

39:59
were mentioning recently, we're on the

40:00
phone and you were mentioning there's a

40:02
um there's a research team you're part

40:04
of. There's four of you

40:06
and it's primarily revolving around

40:08
portfolio structuring.

40:10
Tell us about that that uh that locked

40:13
room that you guys are sitting in and

40:14
what you guys are working on because

40:16
that sounds fascinating that four of the

40:18
brightest people on the planet in this

40:20
in this space are talking about

40:22
portfolio structuring. What are you

40:23
working on?

40:25
Yeah, it's really fun. And we just

40:27
started this team at the beginning of

40:28
January and um it's several of my

40:31
longtime Morning Star colleagues and the

40:34
idea is that at Morning Star we have

40:36
these deep teams that are associated

40:39
with doing individual security research.

40:41
So we've got a team of mutual fund

40:43
researchers, ETF researchers. We've got

40:46
a big stock research team.

40:48
We have fewer people working on

40:51
financial planning matters, retirement

40:53
planning, portfolio planning matters and

40:56
it's a very rich territory. And we also

40:58
find that the

41:00
community the community of financial

41:03
advisors and individual investors and to

41:05
some extent the institutional community

41:07
really needs the help in some of these

41:09
areas. I think that we have a lot of

41:12
financial advisors who came of age in an

41:14
environment where their secret sauce was

41:17
how do I put together an investment

41:19
portfolio

41:20
and you know what are the specific

41:22
investments I choose for my clients.

41:25
Many adviserss are recognizing that yes

41:27
perhaps I can add value there but there

41:30
are all these other areas where I might

41:33
add add value as well. So internally

41:35
we've kind of called them gamma factors.

41:37
So there's alpha, beta, and there's

41:39
gamma where those are the all the other

41:42
levers that you have to improve your

41:45
plan's outcome. So those would be things

41:48
like smart social security

41:50
decisionmaking,

41:52
uh how to asset allocate for retirement,

41:56
what's a safe withdrawal rate in

41:58
retirement. So we feel like we have a

42:00
very broad toolkit which is a little

42:02
overwhelming but also super fun. And um

42:05
an example of the some of the research

42:07
we've been working on. In the first

42:09
quarter, we put out a research paper

42:11
that examined the correlations among

42:13
various asset classes. And what we

42:16
concluded was that asset correlations

42:19
have trended up over the past couple of

42:21
decades that we're seeing assets that

42:24
historically had behaved differently

42:27
come closer together. So an example

42:29
would be real estate, equities, REITs.

42:32
We've noted that when we look at

42:34
correlations with the broad equity

42:36
market, they've come more closely

42:38
aligned. And so, um, the paper concluded

42:42
that there are a few asset classes that

42:44
still do provide really good balanced

42:46
for equities. It comes down to treasury,

42:49
bonds, really across the interest rate

42:51
spectrum, and cash. those two assets.

42:54
Generally, if you're looking for

42:56
something that will zigg when your

42:57
stocks zag, you probably want to ensure

43:01
that your portfolio includes cash and

43:04
treasury bonds. So, th those are the

43:06
kinds of projects that we're we're

43:08
working on. We have um also been toiling

43:11
in the retirement income space and

43:13
you'll see some research from us uh

43:15
forthcoming on that topic as well.

43:17
last topic that I want to cover with

43:19
you. It's been fantastic for I mean my

43:22
listeners are just I'm going to get all

43:23
the love emails and I'll just forward

43:25
them to you. But [laughter] uh I mean I

43:28
mean it's been great and I hope to have

43:29
you on again. But I wanted to talk to

43:31
you about your bucket approach and

43:33
bucket approach um investing and

43:35
portfolio um uh the way you put together

43:38
the portfolio. This is nothing new.

43:40
Okay. The bucket approach it's been

43:42
used, excuse my French, it's been

43:45
bastardized. it's been it's it's been

43:47
improperly shown.

43:49
Can you explain to people the bucket

43:50
approach and how it might help them with

43:53
their planning?

43:54
Yeah, thanks for that question, Stan. I

43:57
always say I did not invent the bucket

43:59
approach. This strategy um really came

44:01
on my radar. I was talking to Harold

44:03
Deky who is a retirement um person and

44:08
professor

44:09
and and his wife Dana Catz. Right.

44:11
Exactly.

44:11
Yeah. They're they're fant he's he's out

44:13
of Texas Tech University. that's where

44:14
he bases his program. Um, but Harold

44:17
Devinsky is is a thought leader, not to

44:19
interject too much on just retirement

44:22
planning as a whole. He's kind of the

44:23
godfather a little bit.

44:24
Yes.

44:25
And um, you know, but but Christine's

44:27
sitting pretty close toward him on all

44:29
this, but yeah, but but go ahead with

44:31
that.

44:32
Yeah. So I I was talking to Harold um

44:35
gosh it must have been close to I don't

44:37
know 12 years ago or so and I was asking

44:39
him I was thinking very much about this

44:41
yield issue the fact that yields then

44:43
were pretty low too. So just talking to

44:46
him about all the dimensions of how he

44:48
crafts his clients portfolios and I

44:50
asked him that question about well like

44:53
how how do you do it and how do you keep

44:56
your clients comfortable with portfolios

44:59
today that back then that should include

45:02
healthy allocations to equities. And his

45:05
comment was that well I use this kind of

45:07
bucket system and I know Harold has

45:08
evolved a little bit on this view over

45:10
the years but basically he said he took

45:13
one to two years of his clients cash

45:16
flow needs and held it in cash alongside

45:19
the total return balanced portfolio that

45:22
he was running for them. And what he

45:24
said was that he found that it gave his

45:27
clients an incredible amount of peace of

45:29
mind to sit tight with the long-term

45:31
portfolio knowing that they knew that

45:34
their cash flows for the next couple of

45:37
years were were pretty much secured.

45:39
Um, and he said sometimes he would call

45:41
his clients on the markets down days and

45:43
ask, "Well, how are you feeling about

45:46
this big market shock?" back and

45:47
basically his clients would say, "No,

45:49
I'm okay because I've got this cash

45:52
buffer, this bucket." And so a light

45:54
bulb went off in my head because I, you

45:56
know, I'm so attuned to the behavioral

45:58
aspects of all of this. You know, if we

46:01
optimize a retirement plan, but people

46:03
can't live with it and and it makes them

46:05
uncomfortable. Well, that's not worth

46:07
anything. We want the plan that people

46:09
will be able to live with and be

46:10
comfortable with. And so Harold made the

46:13
point that doing this gives the clients

46:16
peace of mind. So that's really um led

46:18
me to provide guidance on how you might

46:22
sort of incorporate this bucket system

46:24
into your own plan. And the way I think

46:26
about it is that you're using maybe two

46:29
years worth of anticipated portfolio

46:32
withdrawals and you're holding that

46:33
money in cash investments and then from

46:37
there you're stepping out on the risk

46:39
spectrum. So you're holding highquality

46:42
fixed income investments with the next

46:44
bucket. So your cash buckets bucket one.

46:47
Bucket two would be sort of your

46:48
highquality bond bucket. And that's

46:51
holding maybe another five to eight

46:53
years worth of portfolio withdrawals.

46:55
And with those two buckets, you've

46:58
effectively built yourself a bull work

47:00
that you could spend through if you

47:04
we're talking about sequence of return

47:06
risk. If you're one of those retirees

47:08
who walks headlong into a really bad

47:10
equity market,

47:11
yeah,

47:11
well, with your buckets one and two,

47:13
you've given yourself a set of assets

47:15
that you could spend through and maybe

47:18
not have to touch your equity holdings

47:21
for another 10 years, which should give

47:23
them the opportunity to recover. So,

47:26
that's kind of the basic structure. I

47:28
know that there are a lot of different

47:30
variations, but that's how I approach

47:32
it. And I think it's kind of an

47:34
intuitive way to visualize what a sane

47:38
asset allocation for retirement might

47:40
look like. And it's also just a way to

47:43
build yourself a portfolio that you

47:45
could live with and that would give you

47:48
peace of mind to stick with it to stick

47:50
with the long-term investments through

47:53
um various forms of volatility that

47:56
might materialize.

47:58
I'm going to tell you this has been a

48:00
this has been a great conversation. And

48:02
I know my listeners and viewers have

48:03
enjoyed it as well. Remember who this is

48:05
if you don't already know. Christine

48:06
Benz, she's the director of personal

48:08
finance for Morning Star and a senior

48:11
columnist at Morningstar.com.

48:13
We're going to have her links to her

48:15
archives on my site. We're going to have

48:17
the links to her podcast recordings on

48:18
my site. And I encourage you to start

48:20
following her following her if you don't

48:22
already. Um Christine, thank you so much

48:25
for being here. any any final thoughts

48:27
for the the retirees, pre-retirees or

48:31
postretirees that are tuning in?

48:34
Well, one thing I always like to say,

48:36
Stan, is as much as I like to help

48:39
counsel the DIY type investors, people

48:42
who have done,

48:43
you know, their own portfolio plans. I

48:46
would say this is an area where it

48:48
really helps to get some help. Get at

48:50
least a second set of eyes on your plan

48:53
to make sure you're just thinking

48:54
through your own situation. And it may

48:58
not be that you are, you know, engaging

49:01
with an adviser where you have to pay

49:03
him or her forever, but at least get a

49:05
second set of eyes on that plan to make

49:08
sure that you're thinking things

49:09
through. And the other nice thing about

49:11
engaging some sort of a professional

49:13
either on a short-term or a long-term

49:14
basis

49:15
is that you are building in kind of a

49:18
backup plan that if something should

49:21
happen to you, there is someone

49:23
somewhere who knows kind of the broad

49:26
contours of whatever plan you were

49:28
using. I'm a big evangelist for this

49:30
idea of getting a a little bit of help

49:33
with your plan even though you're very

49:35
engaged and you know might consider

49:37
yourself very savvy about these matters.

49:39
to just get another set of eyes on the

49:41
plan.

49:42
Sage advice from an absolute financial

49:45
advice superstar and recognized

49:47
financial advice superstar, Miss

49:49
Christine Benz. Thanks for joining us. I

49:51
really appreciate it. It's been it's

49:52
been an honor and a privilege and hope

49:54
you can join us again soon uh on the

49:56
number one annuity podcast on the planet

49:59
and we will see all of you next week on

50:01
all major podcast platforms and on the

50:03
Fun with Annuities YouTube channel.

50:05
Thanks again, Christine Benz.

50:09
[music]

related videos

What Is A Life Insurance Annuity?
What Is A Life Insurance Annuity?
MYGAs Are Annuity Bonds: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
MYGAs Are Annuity Bonds: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
What Does A 10-Year Certain And Life Annuity Mean?
What Does A 10-Year Certain And Life Annuity Mean?

Talk to Stan The Annuity Man® himself

Get Stan for 30 minutes. No cost for his 3 decades of experience. Prepare yourself for the brutal annuity truth.

Book Your Call with Stan