Are Indexed Annuities A Good Investment?

August 26, 2026
7 min
Are Indexed Annuities A Good Investment?
The Annuity Man®
Quick Quote
A real annuity rate with zero strings attached.
Get Started

Are indexed annuities a good investment? In this video, I explain why indexed annuities should be viewed as contracts rather than investments, and why understanding contractual guarantees matters more than anything else. I break down how fixed indexed annuities work, when they may make sense for future retirement income, and the key questions you should ask before putting your retirement money into one.

▶️ WATCH NEXT: https://youtu.be/Dm93pRU-XaA

Watch and Enjoy!
Stan The Annuity Man

Key Moments in this Episode
========================
00:00 Introduction to the Video
00:35 Why Indexed Annuities Are Contracts Not Investments
01:51 How Indexed Annuities Work
02:43 How Gains Can Change Based On Companies
03:13 Truth About Indexed Annuities
04:10 Helpful Resources To Understand Annuities
05:14 Important Advice For Retirees
06:30 Next Steps and Helpful Resources

What To Watch Next:
========================
https://youtu.be/Dm93pRU-XaA

Resources
========================
📞 Book a Free 30-minute Call with The Annuity Man Team:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/book-a-call

📘 Get Your FREE Annuity Owner’s Manual:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/get-smarter/annuity-books

🔢 Use Our FREE Annuity Calculators + Live Rate Feeds:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/annuity-calculators

🎧 Listen to the Fun With Annuities Podcast:
https://youtube.com/@funwithannuities

Learn More About Stan The Annuity Man
========================
Stan The Annuity Man® is known as “America’s Annuity Agent®” and the top independent annuity agent in the United States, licensed in all 50 states. He is a firm believer that annuities should NOT be purchased for market growth and is focused on educating the consumer so that they can make an informed decision on their terms and on their time frame. Stan has published 7 books on the annuity topic and prides himself on being a consumer advocate for all things annuity.

========================
Video by Nate Woodbury
BeTheHeroStudios.com
http://YouTube.com/c/NateWoodbury

#StanTheAnnuityMan
#Annuity
#TheAnnuityMan
#Retirement

  • 0:00 Introduction to the Video
  • 0:35 Why Indexed Annuities Are Contracts Not Investments
  • 1:51 How Indexed Annuities Work
  • 2:43 How Gains Can Change Based On Companies
  • 3:13 Truth About Indexed Annuities
  • 4:10 Helpful Resources To Understand Annuities
  • 5:14 Important Advice For Retirees
  • 6:30 Next Steps and Helpful Resources

0:00
Hi there, Stan the Annuity Man,

0:02
America's annuity agent, licensed in all

0:04
50 states in Puerto Rico. A good

0:05
question today and controversial one.

0:08
Are index annuities a good investment?

0:10
Stan the annuity man. Huh, interesting.

0:14
I'm going to have an interesting take on

0:15
that. Be careful who you ask that

0:18
question to because if you ask it to

0:20
your local agent or pretty much any

0:22
agent, they're going to have a different

0:23
answer than what I'm going to tell you.

0:25
And that's the reason you need to hang

0:27
in there after this.

0:34
[music]

0:35
All right. So, are indexed annuities a

0:38
good investment? First of all, they're

0:39
not an investment. They're a contract.

0:41
And I know you're saying, "Stan, you're

0:43
playing word games. Don't be Dr.

0:45
Semantics with me." No, I'm I'm being

0:47
serious. Annuities, there's many types,

0:50
are contracts. They're contracts issued

0:53
by life insurance companies. And what we

0:55
say is you own them for what they will

0:56
do, not what they might do. You never

0:58
buy hypothetical or theoretical non-g

1:00
guaranteed returns. Never buy an annuity

1:02
for growth. Period. End of story. Which

1:05
blows out of the water 99% factually, by

1:09
the way, 99% of all sales pitches that

1:12
you're going to hear about index

1:13
annuities. So, are index annuities a

1:15
good investment? They're not investment.

1:16
They're contract. An investment is if

1:18
you want to go buy the market, S&P 500,

1:20
ETF, Nvidia, Apple, whatever you want to

1:23
do, mutual funds, that's that's an

1:26
investment. Okay. Um, annuities are

1:29
contracts and and those contracts solve

1:31
for four things. Contractually, the

1:34
acronym is pill. P stands for principal

1:36
protection. I stands for income for

1:37
life. L stands for legacy. The other L

1:40
stands for long-term care. And I ask two

1:42
questions every time to see if you even

1:45
need an annuity. What do you want the

1:47
money to contractually do? When do you

1:48
want those contractual guarantees to

1:50
start? with me using the word

1:52
contractual index annuities just kind of

1:56
get pushed aside

1:58
because the guarant the the returns are

2:01
not guaranteed. The returns are

2:03
hypothetical. The returns are

2:05
theoretical. The returns are potential.

2:08
The returns are might do, not will do.

2:12
That doesn't mean we don't like index

2:14
annuities. We use them as an efficient

2:16
delivery system for income writers. If

2:19
you answered the question, I want income

2:20
and I want income to start in the

2:22
future. That's an index annuity with an

2:23
income writer. But we completely ignore

2:26
the index annuity. The accumulation

2:29
value story for index annuities is

2:32
flawed. For most index annuities,

2:34
keyword most, you can only lock in the

2:37
gains one day per year. The other 364,

2:40
you're an annuity unit.

2:42
for most keyword most index annuities

2:45
the um

2:48
the the gains and how they're calculated

2:51
can be changed at the discretion of the

2:53
annuity company. Give you an example.

2:54
You might know exactly what the cap is

2:57
first year on the index annuity years 2

2:59
3 4 5 6 7 8 9 and 10 at the annuity

3:03
company's discretion. Trust us, sir, we

3:05
have good renewal rates. Really? You're

3:08
gonna go 10 years into an investment

3:10
with trust us, sir.

3:13
Are annuities, our index annuities a

3:14
good investment. If you're dumb enough

3:16
to think an upfront bonus is real money.

3:19
Upfront bonus is candy for the stupid.

3:21
Upfront bonuses

3:23
is garbage. It's part of the overall

3:25
contractual guarantee. If there's a

3:26
hundred pennies in the dollar, there's

3:28
not 130 pennies in the dollar because

3:30
this guy gave us an upfront bonus. Like

3:32
I'm talking.

3:34
Come on. Are index annuities a good

3:37
investment? They're a contract. If you

3:40
want CD returns, maybe. But if you want

3:43
CD type returns, then you better off buy

3:45
a MIGO, which is a multi-year guarantee

3:47
annuity, which is the annuity industry

3:49
version of a CD. Is what I call an

3:51
annuity bond. Guaranteed interest rate

3:53
for a specific period of time. Are fixed

3:56
index annuities a good investment if you

3:57
want market growth? No. Because they're

3:59
not going to give you that.

4:02
If you want market growth, never buy an

4:04
annuity. If you want market growth,

4:06
never buy an annuity. I was on the phone

4:10
yesterday with the guy and I said that

4:11
twice. Then I talked to him about my

4:14
guess and you know what he did? Came

4:15
right back. He goes, "But tell me about

4:16
the best index annuity you have." I

4:18
said, "Sir, you are the rube at the

4:20
table." It didn't go well. I mean, he

4:22
was mad and I don't blame him, but he

4:24
was,

4:27
if I know the facts and I know the truth

4:29
about the product and you keep coming

4:30
back to me and not believing me, what do

4:32
you want me to do? I've written a book

4:35
on it. If you say, "Stan, I don't

4:36
believe you. Prove it. Prove it, you

4:39
scoundrel." Okay. Go to my site,

4:41
theanuityman.com, and download my fixed

4:44
index annuity owners manual and read it.

4:47
I still don't believe you. Okay? Go to

4:48
my YouTube site, Stan the Annuity Man.

4:51
In the search bar, type in fixed index

4:53
annuities and watch hundreds of videos.

4:56
And if you still don't believe it,

4:58
promise me you'll never go to Las Vegas.

5:01
Promise.

5:02
Because you are a sucker. You want it to

5:05
be true. You want that vitamin to work.

5:08
You want that pill to work. I want the

5:11
pill to work.

5:14
Retirement in chapter 2 is not a game.

5:17
This isn't a movie. You don't get

5:18
mulligans and doovers. You make good

5:21
decision on facts. And with annuities,

5:22
you make them on contractual guarantees.

5:24
You do not make them on non-contractual,

5:26
guaranteed, hypothetical hope.

5:29
If you buy the hopes and dreams, you're

5:31
going to own the contractual realities.

5:32
Are index annuities a good investment.

5:34
They're not an investment. They're a

5:36
contract. So, you better understand

5:38
what's in the contract. So, Stan, if

5:40
they're not an investment, they're a

5:41
contract. What's the contractual

5:43
guarantee? You're not going to lose any

5:44
money.

5:46
You know what else is a contractual

5:47
guarantee that you won't lose any money?

5:49
Hole in your backyard. But we like them

5:52
when we use them to deliver the income

5:54
writer. We have no problem with them at

5:56
all. Love them. Love them. Hug and love

5:59
them. Love them.

6:02
But hopes and dreams of market returns.

6:04
Come on.

6:06
Come on. That's rookie stuff. That's

6:08
local stuff. That's Johnny Apple Seed

6:10
agent down the road stuff. That's

6:12
golfing buddy bull. Be careful out

6:15
there, okay? There's a reason on my site

6:18
that you can quote all products except

6:20
index annuities because there's nothing

6:22
to quote. How do you quote a

6:24
hypothetical?

6:26
You don't because it's hypothetical. If

6:30
you go to my site and you do annuity

6:31
quotes in in index annuity there, it's

6:33
just going to take you to schedule a

6:35
call with me so I can just yank you over

6:37
the phone and try to get you thinking

6:39
straight and try to und deprogram you

6:41
from the sales pitch that you received.

6:43
Go to my site, download the book. I know

6:45
you don't believe me, but you know what?

6:47
If you buy an index annuity after this

6:49
thing and not believe in me two years

6:51
from now, have the guts to call me. Have

6:54
the guts to call me and say, "Stan,

6:57
you're right." And I'm gonna say,

6:58
"You're right. I was right. And you're

7:00
it's too late. You you got to stay there

7:02
eight more years because of the

7:03
surrender charge." That's how severe

7:04
this is. This isn't a game. It's in the

7:07
movie.

7:09
This is your retirement.

7:12
And with on that light note above me is

7:14
a video that I shot on how annuities can

7:16
protect your family, help your family.

7:18
I've done that for my family and

7:20
thousands of other clients families that

7:22
we set things up so there's contractual

7:23
guarantees in place whether you're alive

7:25
or dead. I know a lot of you going, "You

7:27
mean I can control it from the grave?"

7:29
You're darn right you can, and I can

7:30
show you how to do it. All right, thanks

7:32
for hanging in there with me. My name is

7:34
Stan the Annuity Man. See you next time.

related videos

Who Offers The Top-Rated Guaranteed Retirement Income Solutions?
Who Offers The Top-Rated Guaranteed Retirement Income Solutions?
Guaranteed Retirement Income Products
Guaranteed Retirement Income Products
Do Not Fund Your Agent’s Incentive Trip: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
Do Not Fund Your Agent’s Incentive Trip: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan

Talk to Stan The Annuity Man® himself

Get Stan for 30 minutes. No cost for his 3 decades of experience. Prepare yourself for the brutal annuity truth.

Book Your Call with Stan