Why You Should Never Annuitize a MYGA: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan

June 21, 2026
7 min
Why You Should Never Annuitize a MYGA: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
The Annuity Man®
Quick Quote
A real annuity rate with zero strings attached.
Get Started

Use Our FREE Annuity Calculators + Live Rate Feeds:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/annuity-calculator/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=calculator

Book a Free 30-minute Call with The Annuity Man Himself:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/book-a-call?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=book_a_call

Get Your FREE Annuity Owner’s Manual:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/get-smarter/annuity-books?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=description&utm_campaign=annuity_books

If you own a Multi-Year Guarantee Annuity (MYGA) or are thinking about buying one, this episode could save you from a costly mistake. Discover why annuitizing a MYGA internally is almost never in your best interest—and how a simple MYGA-to-SPIA strategy can unlock the highest contractual guarantees for your retirement income.

In this episode, The Annuity Man discussed:
- Definition and purpose of a MYGA (Multi-Year Guarantee Annuity)
- Why internal annuitization quotes are usually uncompetitive
- The MYGA-to-SPIA strategy using a 1035 exchange
- Focusing on contractual guarantees over brands and brochures
- Using an independent quoting process across all carriers

Key Takeaways:
- A MYGA is best used as a principal protection tool with a guaranteed interest rate, not as a product you annuitize internally for lifetime income.
- Internal annuitization quotes from MYGA and other deferred annuity carriers are typically uncompetitive compared to independently quoted single premium immediate annuities.
- A MYGA-to-SPIA approach—using a 1035 exchange to move from a matured MYGA into the highest paying immediate annuity—can help secure superior lifetime income guarantees.
- The smartest annuity decisions are made by focusing on contractual guarantees instead of company names, product labels, or glossy marketing materials.
- Relying on a broad, apples-to-apples quote across highly rated carriers helps avoid lazy or biased recommendations that may cost you long-term income.

"With annuities, you're buying it for the contractual guarantees. Period." — Stan The Annuity Man

Watch and Enjoy,
Stan The Annuity Man

LISTEN/WATCH FUN WITH ANNUITIES PODCAST
https://www.youtube.com/@funwithannuities

#StanTheAnnuityMan
#Annuity
#TheAnnuityMan
#Retirement

0:00
Welcome to Shooting It Straight with

0:01
Stan. I'm your host Stan the Annuity

0:03
Man, America's annuity agent, licensed

0:05
in all 50 states in Puerto Rico. The

0:06
founder of CGO contractual guarantees

0:08
only, which means you only own an

0:11
annuity for what it will do, not what it

0:14
might do. Title of the of the speech

0:17
today of the topic today is why you

0:20
should never ever annuititize a MIGA. A

0:24
MIGA is a multi-year guarantee annuity.

0:27
It's the annuity industry's version of a

0:28
CD. Go to my site, you can see live feed

0:31
of the best MIGA rates for your state.

0:32
You can download a MIGA owners manual.

0:34
If you stay on this YouTube channel, you

0:36
can watch a quatrillion MA videos that

0:39
I've done. But but you should never

0:42
annuitize a MA. And annuitization,

0:44
annuitize means to create payments. So a

0:48
MA is a principal protection product.

0:49
You can take interest off the top, never

0:51
touch the principal, or you can let it

0:52
grow and compound tax deferred. But

0:55
every deferred annuity has an

0:57
annuitization feature which means that

0:59
you can convert it at some point in time

1:02
into a lifetime income stream. In other

1:04
words, you can convert it from a MGA to

1:07
a SPIA single premium immediate annuity

1:09
which is the a lifetime income stream

1:11
annuity.

1:13
So the MIGA company will give you that

1:16
alternative of that choice. In in fact

1:18
in your policy when you get it, you're

1:20
going to use us. We're going to take you

1:22
through the process. you're going to buy

1:23
a MIGA if you want principal protection.

1:25
But inside that policy, you'll see

1:27
annuitization tables like if you decided

1:30
to turn it in to a lifetime income

1:32
stream.

1:34
Never do that ever, ever, ever, ever,

1:37
ever because

1:40
99.9999%

1:42
of the time, I I should say 100 because

1:44
it is, but I'm going to say 99.999 to

1:46
make everyone happy. my my people that

1:49
are around me, the handlers.

1:52
The quote from the MA for for an immed

1:54
to turn it into an immediate annuity is

1:56
horrific. It's not competitive.

1:59
So, I've come up with a a strategy

2:00
called MAS to SPIA. Some people say, you

2:03
know what, Stan, I need income five

2:05
years from now, but I don't want I I

2:06
don't want to lose any money right now.

2:08
So, we buy a MA principal protection

2:10
protected get an annual interest rate

2:12
for those five years. And at the end of

2:14
the five years when that MIGA has

2:16
matured and there's no surrender

2:17
charges, we do what's called a 1035

2:20
non-t taxable event doesn't trigger any

2:22
taxes transfer to the highest paying

2:25
immediate annuity after quoting all

2:26
carriers A+ or better in the immediate

2:29
annuity space.

2:33
That's what makes sense.

2:35
That's what works and that's the way to

2:37
get the highest contractual guarantee.

2:39
Now, the issuing MIGA company, they

2:42
would love for you to annuitize that

2:44
MIGA with them because the payout that

2:45
they're going to give you is horrific in

2:48
most cases. It's not competitive if you

2:50
do an applesto apples quote with the

2:52
MIGA annuization quote versus Stan the

2:55
annuity man and team quoting all

2:57
carriers for the highest contractual

2:59
guaranteed single premium immediate

3:01
annuity quote.

3:04
It's one more step, but it's a step that

3:07
is in your financial favor. It's a step

3:10
that we will do for you. It's a step

3:11
that we will handle the paperwork. It's

3:13
a step that's turnkey for you through

3:15
the annuity man.

3:19
But never ever and and this goes with

3:22
this goes for any deferred annuity,

3:24
variable annuities, fixed index

3:26
annuities, MA annuities, traditional

3:29
fixed annuities, whatever it is,

3:31
whatever is deferring, never ever ever

3:34
ever

3:36
annuitize internally

3:40
unless I I guess there's a 1% chance

3:43
that that rate was from 1963 when you

3:46
you're you bought the variable, I

3:48
And that annuitization rate is really

3:50
good. And then you're going to have to

3:52
we're going to have to prove it by

3:54
quoting all carriers and doing an

3:55
applesto apples quote and showing it

3:57
side by side and proving it to both me

4:00
and you that you're getting the highest

4:02
contractual guarantee. That's all I care

4:04
about. If you can prove that

4:06
annuitization inside of your deferred

4:08
type annuity MA variable indexed is

4:11
higher than the immediate annuity I can

4:13
quote with all immediate annuity

4:14
carriers, then have at it. lock it in

4:17
player.

4:18
But I'm just going to tell you it's not

4:20
going to happen. And the annuity

4:22
companies design it that way. They don't

4:24
want you to Well, let's put it like

4:26
this. They're not real thrilled about

4:28
you annuitizing to MGA, but if you want

4:30
to go ahead and do that, they'll give

4:31
you a crappy rate. They'll do that. No

4:33
problem. They'll make money and build

4:35
another building and put your name on

4:36
it.

4:38
But with annuities, I don't care what

4:41
type, you're buying them for the

4:42
contractual guarantees. Period.

4:46
So, if you're buying it for the

4:47
contractual guarantees, you're quoting

4:48
all carriers for the highest number. For

4:52
lifetime income, it's A+ or better. Do

4:54
we care about the name of the company?

4:55
No. Do we care about the name of the

4:57
product? No. Do we care about the

4:58
brochure? No. Do we care about where

5:02
they're located? Headquarters? No. We

5:04
care about the rating and the highest

5:06
number. For lifetime income, A+ or

5:08
better and the highest number.

5:13
A lot of the migas that we recommend um

5:15
that's not for lectto income that's for

5:17
a specific period of time. I always say

5:18
we marry we marry the lectto income. We

5:21
date the mas. There are times that we'll

5:24
recommend you know something less than a

5:26
plus a a minus sometimes b plus carriers

5:30
because they have a high interest rate

5:32
for that specific period of time. And my

5:33
financial analysis and recommendation is

5:36
based upon the fact that I sign off on

5:38
them being able to guarantee that rate

5:40
for that specific term.

5:46
What I don't want you to do is be lazy.

5:48
Now, what I've done at my my company

5:50
here in Las Vegas, that's where the

5:52
headquarters at. Everybody in my B

5:54
building is licensed in all 50 states.

5:56
They're not on commission. They're here

5:57
to help. And I've put this together in a

6:00
very big way. We are the grill in the

6:02
room direct to consumer. We are the

6:04
biggest. We're the biggest in sales.

6:06
We're the biggest brains. We have the

6:08
biggest employ staff.

6:11
We're the biggest. Okay. So, what you do

6:13
is you use us. Don't be lazy. Use us.

6:16
Hey, I've got this MA. I'm thinking

6:17
about creating a lifetime income stream.

6:19
Can you quote the the highest

6:21
contractual guarantees for me? Yes, we

6:23
can. Or you can go to my site and do it

6:24
yourself.

6:28
But don't be lazy. Don't be lazy and

6:30
allow that deferred annuity, index

6:33
annuity, variable annuity, MA,

6:36
just have them annuitize it. Don't do

6:38
that. And don't have some agent advisor

6:39
to tell you to do that because they

6:41
don't know what they're doing.

6:43
MA to SPIA is a great strategy.

6:47
Principal protection with guaranteed

6:49
interest rate for a specific period of

6:51
time and then transition and transfer to

6:53
a lifetime income stream. Fantastic. But

6:56
we have to go quote all carriers. You

6:58
can't annuize internally with the MA.

7:02
Okay.

7:03
You're saying, Stan, you're really

7:05
passionate about a MIGA and

7:06
annuitization. No, what I'm passionate

7:08
about is you not making a mistake. What

7:11
I'm passionate about is you not falling

7:12
for a crap sales pitch. What I'm

7:14
passionate about is you being able to

7:16
tap into 30 plus years of experience and

7:19
the best team in the business that only

7:21
look at contractual guarantees. We're

7:23
not selling the dream.

7:25
We're showing you the contractual

7:27
realities and hopefully those

7:28
contractual realities make sense to you.

7:32
All right, pretty basic. So, MA to SPIA,

7:35
yes. MA to annuitization within the MA.

7:37
Uh-uh. No.

7:40
All right. My name is Stan the annuity

7:43
man. That shooting is straight with

7:44
Stan. Yes, I know. Very colorful today,

7:47
but you know, that's how I roll. I try

7:48
to blend in as best I can. Doesn't work

7:52
out too well. See you next

related videos

How Is An Immediate Annuity Funded?
How Is An Immediate Annuity Funded?
Do Fixed Annuities Have Fees?
Do Fixed Annuities Have Fees?
How Annuities Can Take Care Of Your Family
How Annuities Can Take Care Of Your Family

Talk to Stan The Annuity Man® himself

Get Stan for 30 minutes. No cost for his 3 decades of experience. Prepare yourself for the brutal annuity truth.

Book Your Call with Stan