Beware of One-Trick Annuity Ponies: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan

November 22, 2026
•
10 min
Beware of One-Trick Annuity Ponies: Shootin’ It Straight With Stan
The Annuity Man®
Quick Quote
A real annuity rate with zero strings attached.
Get Started

Book a Free 30-minute Call with The Annuity Man Himself:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/book-a-call-with-stan?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=organic_social&utm_campaign=video_description

Use Our FREE Annuity Calculators + Live Rate Feeds:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/?utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=organic_social&utm_campaign=video_description#quick-quote

Get Your FREE Annuity Owner’s Manual:
https://www.stantheannuityman.com/learn?f4325255_type_equal=books&f4325255_sort_date=desc&utm_source=youtube&utm_medium=organic_social&utm_campaign=video_description#hub

One annuity product—or one carrier—may not fit every financial goal. Stan explains why comparing options matters, and outlines three strategies for people seeking guaranteed income in the future.

In this episode, The Annuity Man discussed:
- The PILL framework and contractual guarantees
- MYGAs as fixed-rate, tax-deferred options
- Risks of relying on one product or carrier
- Concerns about indexed annuity sales practices
- Three strategies for future lifetime income

Key Takeaways:
- Start with what the money needs to contractually do and when the guarantees should begin.
- Compare carriers and product types rather than defaulting to a single option.
- Fixed-rate products and income strategies serve different needs and timelines.
- Future lifetime income may be addressed through an income rider, a Deferred Income Annuity, or a MYGA-to-SPIA strategy.
- Evaluate recommendations by their fit and contractual guarantees—not just a sales pitch.

"You cannot be a one-trick pony and offer the highest contractual guarantee. You just can't." — Stan The Annuity Man

Watch and Enjoy,
Stan The Annuity Man

LISTEN/WATCH FUN WITH ANNUITIES PODCAST
https://www.youtube.com/@funwithannuities

#stantheannuityman
#annuity
#theannuityman
#retirement
#retirementincome
#retirementplanning
#annuities

0:00
Welcome to shooting it straight with

0:01
Stan. I'm your host Stan the annuity

0:02
man. America's annuity agent licensed in

0:04
all 50 states in Puerto Rico. Founder of

0:06
CGO contractual guarantees only which

0:08
means you own an annuity for what it

0:10
will do not what it might do. Today's

0:12
topic is a good one. It's beware of one

0:16
trick annuity ponies. You know, there's

0:18
a saying, hey, you God is just a

0:20
one-trick pony. That means they can only

0:22
do one thing. In the annuity industry,

0:24
unfortunately, even though annuities,

0:26
there's many types are commodity

0:28
products and they solve for four things.

0:30
Principal protection, income for life,

0:31
legacy, and long-term care, that acronym

0:33
is pill. And we only ask two questions.

0:35
What do you want the money to

0:36
contractually do? When do you want those

0:38
contractual guarantees to start?

0:40
Unfortunately, in the industry,

0:43
most of the sales that happen are with

0:45
one-trick ponies. And let me kind of

0:47
explain who those one-trick ponies are.

0:49
Um, first of all, we're we're kind of

0:50
the kind not kind of, we are the largest

0:52
MA distributor, you know, independent

0:55
distributor in the country, licensed in

0:57
all 50 states. And MAS are the industry

1:00
version of a CD, multi-year guarantee

1:02
annuity. You lock in a guarantee for a

1:04
specific period of time. It pays a

1:05
contractual interest rate for that

1:07
duration that you choose. You control

1:09
the asset. There's no fees. There's no

1:11
market attachments. There's no moving

1:12
parts. It's the annuity industry version

1:15
of a CD. And you can use it in all three

1:18
accounts types, IRA, Roth IAS, nonIRRA.

1:21
And in a nonIRRA account, MAS grow tax

1:24
deferred as opposed to if you bought CDs

1:27
in a nonirra cash type account, you have

1:28
to pay taxes on the interest. MAS are

1:31
what the queen and I um use for

1:33
retirement just because the annuity man

1:36
is a growth stock and then any extra

1:37
money we put in MAS because we don't

1:40
want to pay the taxes, it's going to

1:41
roll and we just keep rolling and

1:43
deferring at the end of the duration.

1:45
Okay. But in the MA space, there's a

1:47
couple of onetrick ponies. I have

1:49
nothing against them. In fact, I was at

1:50
dinner with one of their uh main people

1:52
the other night. Uh flew into Vegas to

1:55
see us, etc. We were hoping to get them

1:56
on our platform. Um and it didn't it

1:58
didn't work out. Great people though,

2:00
but they only sell one one thing, and

2:02
they only sell it with one company. So,

2:04
if you go to my MA feed, uh you're going

2:06
to see every single carrier on the

2:09
planet, um except for these one trick

2:11
pony people. And that's fine. And I have

2:13
nothing against them, but they're

2:14
selling one carrier and they're selling

2:16
micos. And that's fine. That's great.

2:18
It's just that I think you should be

2:20
diversified. I think you should shop all

2:22
carriers. Um I just I just believe in

2:25
the way that we're doing it, you know,

2:27
and hopefully in the future um and I've

2:29
talked to both of them, have good

2:30
relationships with them, but I said you

2:32
would do better and sell more if you

2:33
just put your stuff on our platform.

2:35
Now, the reason you got to say, well,

2:36
Stan, why wouldn't more carriers

2:41
just sell direct like that? just sell

2:42
the one one be a onetrick pony. Well,

2:45
they would love to do that. Evil evil um

2:48
little conspiracy theory. That's

2:50
actually true. Carriers, annuity

2:52
companies do not like agents. They

2:54
don't. If they could get rid of agents,

2:56
they would love to do that. They love

2:58
the stuff that I do. Carriers do

3:00
because, you know, we're selling

3:01
contractual guarantees. We're not making

3:03
pie in the sky promises too good to be

3:05
true sales pitches. We're not leaning

3:07
into the the index annuity, you know,

3:09
market upside with no downside story or

3:11
upfront bonuses. We just don't do that.

3:14
Okay? So, we are a unicorn out here. Big

3:16
darn unicorn and a powerful one at that.

3:18
But we're not a onetrick pony. You know,

3:20
I'm asking the questions. What do you

3:22
want the money to contractually do? When

3:23
do you want those contractual guarantees

3:25
to start? An annuity software four

3:26
things: principal protection, income for

3:28
life, legacy, and long-term care. That's

3:31
not a onetrick pony. You know, there's

3:32
there's five specific types of of uh

3:35
products that we sell. They're all

3:36
contractual guarantees. They're all

3:38
fixed annuities. No market attachments.

3:41
If you want market returns, never buy an

3:42
annuity.

3:44
Okay. So, there are there are a couple

3:47
of onetrick ponies out there. And then

3:49
you have your fraternal organizations

3:51
that sell um specific, you know,

3:54
one-trick pony type stuff with one

3:56
carrier. I guess that's it. you know,

3:59
it's um one trick pony is you're selling

4:01
one thing with one carrier. I just think

4:03
it needs to be bigger than that because

4:04
not there's not one carrier that's

4:06
better than the other. The other

4:07
onetrick pony that you really need to be

4:10
aware of and be aware of are the um the

4:14
agents out there that just sell index

4:16
annuities. And index annuities were put

4:18
on the planet in 1995 to compete with CD

4:20
returns. They are not market products. I

4:22
said a long time if if people are going

4:24
to position them as market products then

4:27
it should be regulated by the SEC and

4:29
FINRA but it's not I would I think it

4:31
should be if if someone's going to stand

4:33
up at a seminar and say you're going to

4:34
get market returns and no downside or

4:37
upside you know upside with principal

4:39
protection upside with the market then

4:41
it should be a security

4:44
they're the most missold product on the

4:45
planet you know they talk about up

4:47
upfront bonuses and I don't care what

4:49
you need if you need a you know if you

4:51
have a sprained ankle and a sore throat.

4:53
An index annuity salesperson is going to

4:55
sell you an index annuity. And most of

4:57
the people that do that, they're selling

4:59
one carrier period because they've

5:02
learned the they either that carrier

5:04
either offers the highest commission or

5:06
they know the paperwork well enough to

5:08
fill it out. I know you're saying, can

5:10
it really stand? Is that is it that dumb

5:12
down in most cases? Yeah. And 75% of all

5:15
annuities are sold within a 30 mile

5:18
radius of where the agent lives. That's

5:20
going to change. You know, I'm the

5:22
Amazon of the annuity space. Um, my

5:24
opinion to the Amazon lawyers out there,

5:26
but you know, the correlation, we offer

5:29
everything from a contractual guarantee

5:31
standpoint. You can buy it online. You

5:32
can do 247 365 business. You don't have

5:36
to go to a bad chicken dinner seminar.

5:38
But what drives me crazy are the

5:40
onetrick pony index annuity salespeople.

5:42
I just call them gunslingers. They're

5:43
just that's all they they do a seminar

5:46
and then 200 people in the seminar if

5:48
they're lucky and they feed them a steak

5:50
dinner, which should be the red flag,

5:52
the swallow of food, not the sales

5:54
pitch. And then they pitch one product.

5:56
That would be like if a if a medical

5:59
doctor held a seminar and they only

6:01
talked about one drug, one prescription

6:04
medication. That would be that would be

6:06
medical malpractice. So, for a a

6:09
one-trick pony index annuity salesperson

6:12
to just talk about index annuities as a

6:14
one-sizefits-all,

6:16
that's financial malpractice.

6:18
Period. It is. So, be careful of

6:22
one-trick ponies out there. And I'll

6:23
give you a good example about how how

6:26
this plays out in a unfortunately

6:29
non-fiduciary way. Fiduciary is a person

6:32
that puts your best interest ahead of

6:34
theirs in the financial world. No plaque

6:37
needed. Okay. It's it's you're either

6:39
doing the good b good business or not.

6:41
So if you said to me, Stan, I want

6:44
lifetime income and I want it to start

6:46
five years from now.

6:48
There's two products that do that.

6:50
There's actually three strategies that

6:51
do that. But what does the one trick

6:53
pony person show you? One product. So

6:56
let's let's look at that example. Stan,

6:58
me and the wife, we want lifetime income

7:00
to start in five years. We want to put x

7:01
amount of money in there. Or you want to

7:03
solve for a specific amount. That's

7:05
called income later, by the way. And so

7:08
there's three ways to do that. Index

7:10
annuity with an income writer. One, but

7:12
we shop all carriers for the highest

7:14
contractual guarantee of the income

7:15
writer, A+ or better. The second way is

7:17
a deferred income annuity or if it's in

7:19
an IRA, it's a QAC, same product, but

7:22
deferred income annuity, future income

7:24
stream contractual guarantee. And the

7:26
third way is to buy a MA multi-year

7:28
guarantee annuity. And at the end of the

7:30
duration, you transfer that to the

7:32
highest paying immediate annuity. I call

7:34
that ma spia. So income writer dia ma

7:37
spia. Those are the three ways.

7:40
But what does the one trick pony do?

7:42
They go with the index annuity because

7:44
that's the highest commission product on

7:45
the planet in the annuity world. They

7:47
don't even show the other two. Why

7:49
wouldn't they show the other two? I

7:51
don't know. That's a one-trick pony. You

7:53
got to be aware of that. And I'm not

7:55
against the onetrick pony on the mga

7:57
side, but you can't buy all your migas

7:59
from the onetrick pony. You might buy

8:01
one or two from them if you like them,

8:02
if you like their rating, and then you

8:04
have to pepper the rest of your lading

8:06
or whatever with someone like me that

8:08
offers all carriers.

8:12
One trick pony,

8:15
it doesn't work in almost anything,

8:18
especially in the financial services

8:20
world. And annuities are the only um I

8:23
guess people say, "Well, wait a minute,

8:25
Stan. Annuities have a monopoly on

8:27
lifetime income, which is true. Isn't

8:28
that one trick pony?" No, because

8:30
there's four different types of

8:32
annuities that solve for lifetime

8:34
income. Single premium immediate

8:36
annuity, SPAS, deferred income annuity,

8:38
DAS, qualified longevity annuity

8:40
contracts, QAX, and income writers. So

8:43
yes, there is a monopoly on lifetime

8:44
income. But you know those products are

8:47
different. If you needed income to start

8:49
now or within say a year, that's an

8:52
immediate annuity. If you need income to

8:54
start later, what do we just say? Income

8:56
writers, Diaz, QAX, and migpia.

9:00
Even though I've commoditized and

9:02
stripped out all the sales pitch, we

9:04
still have to shop all carriers for the

9:05
highest contractual guarantee. You

9:07
cannot be a one-trick pony and offer the

9:10
highest contractual guarantee. You just

9:11
can't. You I mean, especially the index

9:14
annuity one-trick ponies because if

9:16
you're saying, Stan, we need lifetime

9:18
income of the future. Who cares about

9:19
the index annuity? We're focusing on the

9:21
income writer. We're shopping all income

9:22
writers for the highest contractual

9:24
guarantee.

9:25
If Johnny Apples Seed agent, the

9:27
onetrick pony wonder in the in the local

9:29
area there that has the radio show is

9:31
talking about this is the best one I've

9:33
seen. Full of crap. Absolutely full of

9:37
crap.

9:39
So beware of those one-trick ponies.

9:43
Not saying they're bad people. I don't

9:44
even know them. What I'm saying is you

9:47
can't be a onetrick pony and and provide

9:51
the correct advice or recommendations to

9:55
two people that are looking for

9:56
contractual guarantees.

9:59
There's not one annuity company that's

10:00
better than the other. That's the reason

10:02
I don't go on incentive trips. I don't

10:03
accept gifts. I don't do any I don't

10:05
even care. I just want to know the

10:07
highest contractual guarantee for

10:08
income. For lifetime income, it's A+ or

10:10
better. For MAS, we can go a little bit

10:12
lower that because we're dating the MA

10:14
company. for marrying the lifetime

10:15
income.

10:17
Just beware if someone's pitching one

10:19
thing and they're quoting one one

10:21
carrier, they need to be showing you

10:23
three to four different carriers that

10:25
solve for that specific solution that

10:28
you're looking for. Okay? So, beware out

10:30
there. One trick ponies don't work. Does

10:34
not work in anything. Especially doesn't

10:36
work in the annuity business. That's

10:38
shoot it straight with Stan. See you

10:40
next time.

related videos

Can I Buy An Annuity Without An Agent Or Broker?
Can I Buy An Annuity Without An Agent Or Broker?
Why You Should Consider Annuitizing Your Roth IRA To Beat The Politicians
Why You Should Consider Annuitizing Your Roth IRA To Beat The Politicians
3 Contractual Ways To Ladder Annuity Lifetime Income
3 Contractual Ways To Ladder Annuity Lifetime Income

Talk to Stan The Annuity Man® himself

Get Stan for 30 minutes. No cost for his 3 decades of experience. Prepare yourself for the brutal annuity truth.

Book Your Call with Stan