Variable Annuity vs Fixed Indexed Annuity

A Variable Annuity and a Fixed Index Annuity are both annuity contracts, but they are very different products.

A Variable Annuity is a security with market-based investment options.

A Fixed Index Annuity is a fixed insurance product designed primarily for principal protection.

The right comparison depends on your financial objective.

Key Takeaways

• Variable Annuities are securities.
• Fixed Index Annuities are fixed insurance products.
• Variable Annuities generally have higher annual fees.
• Fixed Index Annuities provide principal protection from market losses within the terms of the contract.
• Neither product should be purchased primarily for hypothetical market growth.
• If growth is the goal, consider market-based investments directly.

What Is a Variable Annuity?

A Variable Annuity is an annuity contract with investment options often described as separate accounts.

Those separate accounts function similarly to mutual funds.

The value can rise or fall based on market performance.

Variable Annuities are securities and are regulated by FINRA and the SEC.

Why Variable Annuities Were Created

Variable Annuities were originally developed to allow market-based investments to grow tax-deferred inside an insurance contract.

The concept was straightforward.

Over time, many products became more complex and included higher fees and optional benefits.

That complexity is one reason Variable Annuities need to be evaluated carefully.

What Are the Fees on a Variable Annuity?

Variable Annuities can include multiple layers of fees.

The source notes an average annual fee around 3%.

Those fees can include:

• mortality and expense charges
• administrative fees
• fund expenses
• rider fees

That means the investment performance has to overcome those costs before the owner sees the net result.

What Is a Fixed Index Annuity?

A Fixed Index Annuity is a fixed insurance contract.

It protects principal from market losses according to the terms of the policy.

Potential interest is calculated using an external index and a contractual crediting method.

You are not directly invested in the index.

How Fixed Index Annuities Are Different

Fixed Index Annuities are regulated at the state insurance level rather than as securities.

They generally do not have the same type of annual investment management fees as Variable Annuities unless an optional rider is added.

Their purpose is also different.

A Fixed Index Annuity is primarily a principal protection product.

Which One Has More Market Exposure?

The Variable Annuity has direct market exposure through the separate accounts.

The Fixed Index Annuity does not.

That means Variable Annuity values can fluctuate based on market performance.

A Fixed Index Annuity protects principal from market declines but limits the upside through its crediting formula.

Which One Is Better for Growth?

If growth is your primary objective, the source position is that neither should be purchased for that reason.

A Variable Annuity may offer more direct market exposure, but the fees can be significant.

A Fixed Index Annuity is not designed to produce full market returns.

If market growth is the goal, direct market investments may be more appropriate.

Which One Is Better for Principal Protection?

A Fixed Index Annuity is the more appropriate of the two if principal protection is the goal.

It is a fixed product.

A Variable Annuity is exposed to market losses.

That makes the two products fundamentally different from a risk standpoint.

What About Fixed Index Annuity Returns?

Fixed Index Annuities can earn indexed interest.

But that should not be confused with direct stock market returns.

The crediting formula may include:

• caps
• spreads
• participation rates

The result can be much lower than the return of the referenced index.

What About Variable Annuity Tax Deferral?

One of the traditional selling points of a Variable Annuity is tax-deferred growth.

That can be useful in certain situations.

But the source argument is that if the main reason is to own mutual funds, investors should compare the cost and simplicity of owning market investments directly rather than automatically putting them inside a Variable Annuity.

What About Income Riders?

Both Variable Annuities and Fixed Index Annuities can offer optional Income Riders.

These riders can provide contractual lifetime income.

If the goal is income, compare the actual guaranteed income amount rather than the hypothetical accumulation story.

Don't Compare Them Only on Return Potential

The wrong question is:

Which one will grow more?

The better question is:

What financial problem are you trying to solve?

If the answer is market growth, neither may be the appropriate annuity.

If the answer is principal protection, the Fixed Index Annuity is more aligned with that objective.

If the answer is lifetime income, compare contractual Income Rider guarantees.

Annuities Solve Contractual Objectives

Annuities generally solve for:

• Principal Protection
• Income for Life
• Legacy
• Long-Term Care

They are not primarily designed to replace a growth portfolio.

That is why the contractual objective should come before the product comparison.

Start With Two Questions

Ask:

What do you want the money to contractually do?

When do you want those contractual guarantees to start?

Those two questions can often eliminate one or both products from consideration quickly.

Where to Compare Annuity Guarantees

Use our annuity calculators to compare contractual guarantees from multiple insurance companies.

If guaranteed income is your objective, compare current income guarantees. If principal protection is the goal, compare fixed annuity alternatives rather than choosing based on hypothetical market performance.

The Bottom Line

A Variable Annuity and a Fixed Index Annuity are very different products.

A Variable Annuity is a security with market exposure and potentially significant annual fees.

A Fixed Index Annuity is a fixed insurance product designed primarily for principal protection.

Neither should be purchased simply because of a growth sales pitch.

The right choice depends on the contractual problem you are trying to solve.

‍