Annuities vs Other Retirement Options for Someone Retiring

When you are approaching retirement, the financial goal starts to change.
For decades, you may have focused on accumulating money.
Now you have to decide how that money is going to support the next chapter of your life.
That can include annuities, market investments, CDs, money markets, Treasuries, municipal bonds, dividend stocks, and other retirement assets.
The question is not whether annuities are better than everything else.
The question is what job each part of your retirement plan needs to do.
Key Takeaways
- Annuities are contracts issued by life insurance companies.
- Annuities can solve for Principal Protection, Income for Life, Legacy, and Long-Term Care.
- Lifetime income is the unique contractual benefit annuities can provide.
- Other retirement options may provide growth, yield, or liquidity.
- Retirement planning should separate contractual guarantees from potential market growth.
- Your income floor should be one of the first things you evaluate when approaching retirement.
What Are Annuities Designed to Do?
Annuities are contracts.
They are issued by life insurance companies and generally solve four financial objectives through the PILL framework:
- Principal Protection
- Income for Life
- Legacy
- Long-Term Care
Those are contractual goals.
Market growth is not one of them.
What Are the Other Retirement Options?
Other retirement assets can include:
- CDs
- money markets
- Treasury securities
- municipal bonds
- preferred stocks
- dividend-paying stocks
- other market-based investments
Different products serve different purposes.
Some may emphasize safety and yield.
Others may provide market growth.
Annuities belong on the contractual-guarantee side of the retirement plan.
Annuities and Market Investments Are Different
Annuities should not be purchased primarily for potential market growth.
If you want market growth, use products designed for market growth.
With an annuity, the focus should be on what the contract guarantees.
That means separating:
- contractual guarantees
- hypothetical returns
- market-based growth
Those are different things.
Lifetime Income Is the Annuity Difference
Annuities have a unique role when it comes to lifetime income.
They can contractually provide an income stream that continues for as long as you live.
If the contract is structured jointly, income can continue for as long as either covered person is alive.
That is different from a bond or other income-producing asset with a defined maturity.
What Is Your Income Floor?
Your income floor is the amount of money coming into your bank account every month regardless of what is happening in the markets.
That may include:
- Social Security
- pension income
- annuity income
- dividends
- rental income
- other dependable sources
The first retirement question should be whether that income floor is enough.
Social Security Is Already Lifetime Income
Social Security provides lifetime income.
If you also have a pension, that adds another guaranteed income source.
The question is whether those sources provide enough income to support the lifestyle you want.
If not, a lifetime income annuity can potentially fill the gap.
Principal Protection Is Another Annuity Role
You may not need more lifetime income.
Instead, you may want to protect part of your retirement savings and earn a guaranteed interest rate.
A Multi-Year Guarantee Annuity can solve that problem.
A MYGA provides:
- principal protection
- a guaranteed rate
- a specified contract term
It is the annuity industry's closest comparison to a CD.
How Much Risk Do You Want?
Once the income floor is established, determine how much investment risk you still want.
That could be:
- 50%
- 40%
- 30%
- 0%
There is no universal answer.
If you have already accumulated enough money to support your retirement, you may decide you no longer need as much market exposure.
If You've Won the Game, Why Keep Taking the Same Risk?
Retirement changes the purpose of the money.
During the accumulation years, growth may have been the priority.
During retirement, lifestyle and dependable income can become more important.
You may still want market exposure, but you do not automatically need the same level of risk you carried while building the portfolio.
Guarantees Can Help You Stay Invested
Contractual guarantees can also complement market investments.
If your income floor is already in place, you may not need to sell investments during a market downturn simply to cover monthly expenses.
That can allow your investment portfolio to remain invested during periods of volatility.
The annuity does not have to replace the market portfolio.
It can support it.
Think About Your Spouse
Retirement planning should also consider what happens after one spouse dies.
One person in the household may be comfortable managing investments.
The other may not be.
Contractual guarantees can potentially create a simpler income structure for the surviving spouse.
That can be part of the retirement planning decision.
Retirement Is About Lifestyle
The purpose of retirement assets is ultimately to support your life.
You saved.
You invested.
You planned.
At some point, the focus has to shift from accumulation to using the money.
The correct retirement structure should help you live the lifestyle you worked to create.
Where to Compare Annuity Guarantees
Use our annuity calculators to compare current contractual guarantees from multiple insurance companies.
For lifetime income, compare current payouts.
For principal protection and guaranteed interest, compare MYGA rates and terms.
Then evaluate those guarantees alongside the other retirement assets you already own.
The Bottom Line
Annuities and other retirement options do not have to compete.
Market investments can provide growth.
CDs, money markets, Treasuries, and other products can provide safety or income.
Annuities can provide contractual guarantees such as principal protection and lifetime income.
Start with your retirement income floor, determine how much risk you still want to take, and use each financial product for the job it is designed to do.
Talk to Stan The Annuity Man® himself
Get Stan for 30 minutes. No cost for his 3 decades of experience. Prepare yourself for the brutal annuity truth.


